The Archive · 1898

Miscellaneous Articles

WANTED: A HISTORIAN

In the preface to his recently published History of China, the: Rev. J. Macgowan otates that the Standard History and the: works of Confuciis and Mencius are the only authentic sources from which the story of the Empire can possibly be obtained. Many writers during the long ago-of the past have written. the history of their times, but they are unreliable, and valuable only in. go far as they' agres. with the accounts contained in.the above-mentioned work.

Mr. Macgowan proceeds. to- describe the conditions. under. which these official records were produced, and is of opinion: that-accuracy-and veracity: wore secured, because of the inviolable secrecy: which guarded the work of the annalists, and" the immunity from censorship which they enjoyed, But he speedily qualifies this. opinion by the grave admission that "we have no means of proving their falsehood, for there are "largo portions of Chinese history that we cannot know anything about except from this Standard History."

That the existence of these records is a boon to: the student as well as the amateur admits of no question, but that. they contain more than a frac; tion of the information available for a modern. scientific historian, cannot be conceded, he Standard History is chiefly concerned: with dynastic interests and only incidentally with the affairs of that great.people whom such interests have rendered but negatively, happy.and relatively prosperous, Those limitations make Chinese annale so monotonous: to. the general reader and irritating to the scholar. The rise, xonith, decline, and setting of each imperial family afford little variety of outline or detail. The founder line possesses the usual qualities. and defects of a parvenu or a traitor; he almost always evinces " reluctance to mount the throne after he has ejected ite occupant and soaked its steps in blood, but he as surely yields to the importunity of the mob as ever Richard Crookback did. If he be sufficiently shrewd to be ungrateful he may secure the succession for his posterity by cutting off the heads and exterminating the families of his principal lieutenants if he should, on the contrary, ex-pericues a revulsion. in favour of leniency and generosity after assuming the diadem, that symbol of. royalty is almost inevitably, forfeited. in the next generation, Throughout: this sordid and: dreary h tragedy' the masses of the: people are silent, aavo.for. their sighs and.groans amid long: periods. of turmoil. and tyranny;:.without perceptible advancement. in® the arts: of peace or war. Chinese' wioralists reiterate the phrase that,.when. the. court is virtuous, the people: will: be tranquil; and: when the: raler-is profligate the lower. orders will be turbulent, This aphorism, however respectable for its age, is utterly untrue in any.degres of civilisation where the government is dependent not upon the the will of the nation but upon the. ferocity or the finesse of-an individual, fortified by: a pretended commission as Heaven's Vice-regent.

Conspicuous ability to administer public business may, and often does, go hand in hand with gross irregularities of private life and. a disregard of the homely virtues, nor do the possession and practice-of domestic morality carry with them in all cases the talent' of raling or- securing the happiness of multitudes, What Dr, Johnson thought of the logic of' such axioms was-expressed in his famous parody "Who drives fat oxen must himself' be fat."

In China the lean kine certainly prevail, but the herdsman with few excaptions are blessed with adipose tissue.

Only the type of mind which pores with pleasure over estalogues of first editions and accumulates cancelled postage stamps with miserly delight can thoroughly appreciate the sort of Chinese-history which has thus far been offered to the western world. Some of it exhibits immense research, absolutely devoid of balanced judgment, much of it is careless compilation with inadequate scholarship and ignorance of the country, like the work of D. C. Boulger, while other treatises, perfect in their ay, do not aspire to deal with every side of the subject, nor to show the whole in relation to its parts. These efforts are of little use to the stu-dont of humanity or to those whose calling or livelihood has set them among the teeming millions of the Orient. They want, not an index of dates nor a table of dynasties, but a history of the Chinese people, their emergence from the nomadic to the agricultural state, the growth of their institutions, the influences which brought under one authority the vast area which they colonized, the philosophic speculations and religious notions which. have crystallized among. them, the expansion of the national mind as shown in its literary and. decorative products, Specialists have treated all these matters: with varyi man can garner so hi But tha writer who can analyse, apportion, and condense these results so as to. present them to: mankind in 3 convenient and interesting form has yet' to appear. We ses here and there small heaps of priceless tiles saved from the Porcelain Tower, but only a-genius can reconstruct it, Yet rich mine for some workman of order to which John Richard Green in. England. and John Bach McMaster in America belong, the historians of a people as distinguished from. their princes. No. testimony is too humble or obscure for the-attention each. scholars;. no stray. human document' -eseapes them, no mere inventory of titles, imaginary dialogues of ancient worthies "composed "by rhetoricians, not as they were but as they ought to have been spoken, will suffice. What person, it may be asked, can possibly combine the knowledge of Chinese literature and sympathy with the lot of the common people, together with the sense of historic proportion adequate for the performance of such a task?.. Have not the sinologues acted wisely and modestly in confining their labours to single branches? Mr. L.

Hopkins in the preface to translation of Gob's "Kuan Hua Chih Nan" has cynically observed that "fow foreign residents of China, will challenge the proposition that to speak of a man as a sinologue is to think of him as a fool." It is. far from our intention to imply anything of the sort, but it is open to doubt whether the class of sinologues will ever afford the right kind of material for a historian of the people. Their researches will aid him infinitely in certain directions, but they: will quite'as surely hamper him in others, The sinologue is apt to busy. himaclf with vexed and tortured readings of Confucian or Taoist works which have little or no bearing on the subject in hand. The elaborate beauties of Chinese belles lettres to which he has finally been initiated are prone to blind senso of perspective and distort the vision with which he regards the great movements of mankind. The Chinese nation, however unconsciously, has followed other ideals than those. set forth in the classics. Literatura. in Cathay has been divorced from reality; the less @ thesis approaches: the-bor-doriand of daily experience the. more it will appeal to the high priests of culture. It is the province of historian to show how this came about snd why the freshness and simplicity: of the Book. of Odes have. given way: to a poetical patch-work' appreciated mainly by pedants, He will not: waste his precious time. and the still more. precious patience of his readers' by: merely erudite quotations or voluminous foot-notes, nor will he. convey a-sense of fatuity. by citing: instances rudely torn from: their contexts. Literary form is naught to him save' in so for as it configures the spirit: of the race by whom it was created, Are-we to seek a Green or a McMaster among the "chials" who put a girdle about the earth with a rubber tire and on their return try to expound the Cycle and the Acupuncture of Cathay to the innocents of the Occident? Or shall we believe in one to the manner born and invite a frosh instalment of Les Morveilleur Récits clu General Jone-Qui-Tonne? Far from it, Neither do we hope for anything from those devoted bookworms who, without stirring beyond the rays cast by a-midnight lamp, have evolved from the depths of dusty volumes " complete Chinese folk-lore, jurisprudence, and physics such as the earth never saw and-never will see,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account