The Archive · 1893

A Shipmaster

This pseudo-Court savours more of red tape wud cotton yarn, than it does of the curves, double altitudes, or the treachery of subtle curren our legislators so passed able tot the ques form Court according to his own sweet will is beyond my comprehen: sion, No thought can be taken of justice, when this happens; such " Courtanay be justifiable in some outside, or out of the way corner of the world where wilk alone can be found, and no cream, but there necessity' to form such " Court i places where there is a superabundance of the very best article, which may be had for the askin:

It cannot be said of Government officials who ndupt this course that they exer-cive excessive jurisdiction in the dire tion of equity, but on the contrary, the mum limit of ellicieney seems the one thing aimed st, which the mak the buw never anticipated would be dre: ut of, except in very exceptional cases.

Tf the composition of all Naval Courts were in accord with the spirit of the law, Courts are cianposed. of three few indeed evuld complain sucht

only, one single shipmaster can seldom make his voice heard to any effect paid servants of the Crown, and he. utterly silenced as though he never existed.

Whew of the Merelmut Shi ping Act was passed into law whit the mercantile marine a majority on Courts of five members, our legislators hi full confidence in the sterling British shi master and judyed him capable of dvi his duty inch ingly, even as a member of such a Court, Why then should he be employed in h fall strength om auch The duties of a Naval Court very onerous, far more indeed thaw it ordinarily appears. It is not called to take a chai of evidence leading up to convieti crime, but on the contrary, whilst liste: to evidence, it should carry itself—only the imagination—to the sce of perhaps some awful catastrophe and into the fog. the bl the perplexity realise, not only what was in the man who—under great trials—had wd did act to the very best of his should ask themselves this not this man act as most oan, would have done, without li the alter knowledge ihat xe come to light? It not the duty of a. Court.to brand a juan. j culpable because his judgment Jed bin the wrong way, oF. led him: tode something that would not: have done. if he shad: known ist what it was impossible to discover, What? would be thought, if when an honest bankrupt came' before thie Registrar he was refused his discharge-on the ground that itted an error of judgment in one OF his speculations? Ain error of judg. _ment was committed, hundreds, of vor people ruined, and, "yet, f the bankrupt goes free. na tives: were "discovered, ertuc-of judgment, that start business again to-mon How very differentisit with the mariner? He por fel uni stake, commits judgment, and is too frequent in" moat scandalous manner, Thave even known men to suffer who were perfectly ianecent of even cunuitting, the slightest error'of judgment, Why?-Because of the worse than puerile Courts that tried the cases, The commercial nn.ie rightly acquitted for x, pure error of judguient, and why should wt the same law apply, to one of Neptune's sons?

Happily there is such @ thing as "Full and Change," we have had the "Full" the "Change" is now upon us, and we rejoice to see the bright example svt by Hongkong. Such change is really needed, all round, #0 that justice and equity may yo hand in hand together, change however, ix not singular to Chi has reached Scotland, only: in another form.

A fine, clear-hended, and fearless man—Mr. Sheriff J. Campbell Smith, Judge ut Board of Trade Inquiries at Dundee—of whom Ishould say few are his peers for sound logical deductions and conclu is another champion of the change that is setting in.

The following is quoted from Mr, Sherif J. Campbell Sini b's report on the stranding'of the von of Dundee respect, and am Lound to respect skilled nautical opinion on nautical matters, but' am not bound by nautical opinion in criminal law. Before there can be either wrongful negligence or default there must, in my opinion, be an element of conscious, positive wrong-laing, failure to do What is known to Now, wrong or failure todo the right The Captain, I fully realise, umitted an error, or series of errors in judg"

OF rather failure to exercise judyment appropriate to the exit Hie cardinal error, and the fatal parent of the ies of the moment.

rest, was that he was deceived by the appa: rent clearness of the night ince the belief that be could not come within two miles of. the land without seeing it. Had this belief been well founded all would have gone well, The result proved that it was not well founded but a man is not to be condemned by results and after-hand knowledge, he must be judged Cly the light that he had when he formed the belief. Am I then to hold that the Captain was utterly reckless, raslt, thoughtless, and foolhardy when he thought himself safe to believe this eyes in regard to the clearness of All the witnesses seem to have deceived by it, more Captain Sutherland of the steamer Queen, Who was similarly though not equally irprised in the early dawn of the same morn-ug to find himself within a quarter of " mile off Copinshay, though he had expected to see it eight or ten times that distance off. 1 am not rears cobdente a be with A serious penalty for too readily Delieving his eyes. His belief' may nave been juccutious, "un: scientific, even childish, but I cannot hold it to be criminal. Certainly in' its tion: it could not be." We are all compelled to believe our eyes, though often obliged to correct their erroneous reports by scientific eritical adjustment. Tenn only wonder—it is easy sitting on shore to wonder—why he should have been so readily credulous a to what he thought he could see, and so dull to apprehend

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account