25rd Feb.
Wuew the Russians took a lease of Port Arthur and lien wan, they declared that they still recognised the sovereignty of the Emperor of China. Now we hear from native sources that disturbances have arisen through the Russian authorities endeavouring to exact land tax from the Chinese, and that "some tens of Chinese have been killed. But surely the collection of the land tax is the prerogative of the Sovereign, not of the les 24th Feb.
WE regret very much to find that we are charged by the Committee of the China Association with mis. representing the views of the community in the matter of the demand of the French for an extension of their Settlement. That while on the 5th and 20th of December we published articles which were entirely im harmony with the views held by the China Association, the Chamber of Commerce, the Municipal Council, and the representatives of German, American, and Japanese nationalities, the articles which we printed on the Sth and 24th ult. and sundry brief criticisms that have since appeared in our columns, have shown a complete change of front on our part, and a culpable extenuation of what the China Association regard important matter of principle.
Touching the question of principle, may remark that when the French were believed originally to be claiming only the inclusion of the Pabsienjao district in their Settlement, the China Association itself made no dif. culty whatever, It was only when the French claim was understood to include the hinterland of the French Settlement as far as Sicawei, the Chinese Bund, and territory in Pootung, and the French farther insisted that British registered property should be re-registered at the French Consulate-General, that the China Association protested. Then the question treated as one of principle, and the China Association registered its objection to the French getting any extension whatever. This is where we parted company with the China Association, as soon as the French claim was reduced {again to the Pahsienjao district, and the stipulation as to the compulsory registration' at the French Consulate-General of land belonging to foreigners not being Frenchmen was abandoned.
Our article of the 5th of December Hlast was writ..a when it was understood that the French Consul-General was pressing the full claim and still insisting on complete jurisdiction jover the land to be added to the existing French Settlement. This, as Iwe said, was "nothing more or less than a demand for alienation of ten tory and was utterly at variance with the notorious assurance of the Chinese Government that_no territory will be alienated in the Yangtze provinces." Tewas understood that the French were still pushing their full claim when we {wrote on the 20th of December last, that it seemed "a mistake to base a claim for the extension of the French Settlement on the Ningpo Joss-house affair, and to make that claim a preposterous one in extent, so that it does not enlist the sympathies of other Powers, who also entirely object to any expansion of the exclusive jurisdiction which the French cnforce in the Settlement they have now and have been allowed to enforce although it has no foundation in right." We pointed out that the concession by the Chinese of the whole of the Count de Bezaure's demands would infallibly lead to a riot, and that "no one member of a cosmopolitan community has a right for what seems to him his own advantage to provoke a riot which will endanger the persons and property and the trade of all the other member: So far, as we have said, it is acknowledged that we were in complete accord with our critics.
Now, as to our change of front. We do not deny it. But the question had changed its front completely. Tempore mutant, nos et mutanur in illls. In our article of the 5th ult,, to which exception is taken, we deprecated, and here we are sure that a large number of our readers agreed with us, the exaggerated importance attached to the question, as we learned through Renter, by the London Times; and now that the full text of the articles in the Times has reached us, we fully confirm: what we wrote. Our article was intended i We said We do not allow the French claim, if it is made, that the present French Settlement and any extension of it, are any n French territory, than the so-called British Settlement is British, or the American Settlement American territory. The disadvantages have been so practically uni portant. that we have not in the past made any effective protest against the Regulations under which the French claim exclusive control over their Settlement; and if no wore practical injury is done to the general terests in the future than in the past by the French extending these Regulations to the Pahsienjao district, it may be really worth while to allow this rather than to permit the extension of the cosmopolitan tlement to be impeded by our ob-
Tt was understood when the above was written that the French demand had been cut down to the Pahsienjao district, in the grant of which the China Association itself was quite ready originally to acquiesce. We added Undoubtedly the best solution for all, the French included, would be that the
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.