The Indian Currency Committee has resumed its sittings this week, and itis to be hoped that it will soon be able to conclude ite enquiry. Of the evidence thst is now being taken, it is, of course, impossible to speak, since most unwisely, as it seems to us, the Committee continues to sit incomerd. We trust, however, that it is getting more assistance from the witnesses that are being examined than certain outside critics, who have undertaken to instruct it in the way it should go, seem able to afford. Tuke, for instance, an article under the sensational title, Shall the Indian ment Ruin India? which appears in the current number of the National Review. In that the closing of the mints is roundly denounced on the ground that it amounts to something like robbery. "Tke great mass of the people of India," says the writer, has invested its savings in i ventured to estimate that ings of the Indian populati time are, at the very lowest, ili steeling. I may.add that I believe the real amount to be v-ry much greater. The policy of the Indian Government in closing the mints has already depreciated in rupees this immense holding by about one-third, or, say, 100 millions sterling." Now, obviously, such calculation as this is absurd. Whether the guess at the amount of the hoards of silver in India be near or wide of the mark we need not stop to enquire. But everyone knows that a large Proportion of these hoards consists of coined rupees, and as regards that portion, the closing of the mints, instead of being prejudicial, has been _benefi holders. And as regards th consists of silver ornaments, it is only in the relatively trifling amount that in times of trial their owners may be compelled to part with thet any loss due to the action of the Government can occur.
exaggerated language such as that to}
people, only suggest that the person em-stich we have refered cam, to tensonable ploying Hfinde bimselE very hard pressed for sound argument. And this impression ance because it recognises this patent fact is utterly preposterous.
Passing from the Iucubrations ut the writer in the National Review, a few words on a matter of mora roll importance may not be out of place. The Indian and Ceylon tea-planters ate complaining very strongly that the action of the Indian Government in enhancing the exchange value of the rupee would otherwise lieable to reap. They argue depriving them of profit which they that the lower the exchange, the greater number of rupees does the gold price of their product r present, mal as there is no corresponding rise in the cost production, the greater their profit, One answer that has been made to this is, that the tea producers have no vested right to a depreciated currency; but be that as it may, is it really the case thata fall in the exchange valu of the rupee would work thus to their advantage? In such a matter everything depends upon the condition of the industry. If it were the case: that the dewand for tea was fully equal to, or in excess of, supply, than it is probable that any larger margin of profit due to a fall in exchange could be retained by the producer. But the real state of affairs is very different. The production has outstripped, and threatens to run still further ahead of, the demand, The industry, too, is for the most. part in the hands of a number of joint stock companies whose shareholders are eager for dividends, and who are apt to make it uncomfortable for the directors and all concerned if their ox-pectations aren't realised. Each company, therefore, is keenly competing for a share of the current business. In these circumstances is it not almost inevitable that any enlargement of the margin of profit which might result from a depreciation of the rupee would lead to a cutting down of prices, and that the benefit would go, not to the producer, but to the- consumer? 'That, it appears to us, is a phase of th question to which the' tea-planters have not, so far, given the consideration it
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.