The Archive · 1899

Before Joux Goopxov, Esq., Consul

General

U.S. Provue v. Moxno.

Frank Monte; seaman' of the American sniling vessel E, K: IVood, was charged with being drunk and disorderly on Saturday in Broad way.

The case having. been proved, prisoner was ordered to be put aboard his'ship.

17th January.

Before Mu. J. Goopsow, Consul-General, Acting Judicially, and Mr.

Bexserr and the Rev. Dr. H¥Kes, Assessors.

Suenvry v. Doctor.

'This was a claim by G. J. Shekury, broker, against' A. Docter'for Tls. 2,325 in respect of 26° International Cotton Mill shares which the defendant had failed to take up on the Slst of Dec mber, according to contract. Mi? H. Browett) appeared for the plaintiff;: und' the defendant conducted his own case.

'The plaintiff said that on the Gth of September he sold' to the defendant, through Mr. Elias, 26 shares in the International Cotton Mill, for delivery on the Bist December: Witness attended at the Central Hotel on that day five times, but could not find the defendant, and he then left a letter for. him. plaintiff; was frequently. stopped by his Uononr and told that his questions were irrelevant, as parole evidence seeking set the writteti contract before thi Jour could not be allowed."

Defendant said -he wished to show that nature to the contract was obtained by misrepresentation.

Plaintiff, further cross-examined, said that the contract was signed by him for the-cone-med." He refused at the time to tell Mr. Doctor who was the seller, but, would, if desired by the Court, now Defendant was further questioned by the plaintiff as to how long he had been a ker, and as to certain business in Singupore.

His Honour—Here is a plain. om tract igned_by Mr. Shekury and accepted by I might make 4 contract with a oolie down in the street, and it would hold youd whether that evolve had been in the Mixed Court half his life. I hope yon understand, Mr. Shekury, that in making that iMustration Tdo not intend to reflect upon-you.

Plaintiff' denied that. there was any. agreement in regard to the contract other than-appeared on the face of it, His Honour observed that if Mr. Doctor were seeking to make-out that he hnd been deceived by his representative, or go-between, his remedy was -against: that go-between.

Mr. John William Graham, a member of the Brokers' Association, of Shanghai, was-called to give evidence as to the form of contract in the present case being customary, but His Honour said it was not necessary.

The Chinese hall-porter at the- Central Hotel gave evidence corroborating the plaintiff's statement as to his visits to the hotel on-the 3ist_of- December, in search of Me. Docter.- He also spoke to n letter being left by plaintiff addressed to the defendant.

This closed the plaintiff's case.

Mr. P. W. Irvine, in the firm of Messrs. Sylvx & Ca., share brokers, was called by the defendant and asked to explain the meaning of certain terms, but his Honour. ruled that the evidence was inadmissible.

The Court at this stage rose for the day.

18th January. Suexury v. Docrer.

'The hfearihy of' this case, arising out of a claim by G. J. Shekury, a broker, against A. Doctor for Tls. 2,325 in respect of 25 Thternational Cotton' Mill shares which the defendant' tind failed to take up on' the Bist of December, accor to contract, was concluded. Mir. H: Browett appeared for the plaintiff, and the defendant conducted his own case.

J. R. Elias was called by the plain-object of showing that the transaction was to be a matter of difference, and the shares were not intended to be handed over. The witness, however, could not remember this.

'The plaintiff gave evidence in support of his case, but no questions were asked by Mr. Browett. 'The plai the Court, quoting fro Ordinance' requiring the nunsbers of the shares to be given, which, however, he could not say applied to Shang!

Mr. Browett, in reply, contended that the contract was a val 1 all essentials; and after quoting from the case of Bibb Allen, from the American law reports urged thit the plaintiff had used his best endeavours to deliver the shares.

Judgment was reserved. if THE LOSS OF THE

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account