The Archive · 1899

Miscellaneous Articles

THE TREATY OF PEACE BETWEEN SPAIN AND THE UNITED STATES

25th Jan, We have received from Mr. H. de Uriarte, the courteous and popular Consul-General of Spain whom we are so soon to lose, a copy of a pamphlet of 78 pages with the above heading, without any author's, printer's, or publisher's name, in' English, but obviously not printed in any English-speaking country. The author describes himself as placed in an independent position, and as reviewing the points under discussion "with the impartial eye of one who professes as much sympathy for the noble nation conquered as for its powerful conqueror;" he more than once asserts his impartiality, notwithstanding which his pamphlet is an able, but. entirely one-sided brief for Spain, and its style as well as its matter shows conclusively that it was not written by one to whom English is his native language. In his opening remarks he states that he proposes to discuss two points; "the first of these points is the one relating to the recognition and payment of colonial debis, the second to the claim and title to the occupation of pit of the, Phi lippine Islands, which the United States may invoke." The> first few pages, however, are devoted to a condemnation of the, United States for going to war with Spain at all, the writer being -especially severe on the operations in the Philippines, "where the United States have also made the most of, and fomented a rebellion, as an auxiliary to their arms. Such conduct may fit in more or less with the modern character of the modern struggle of civilised nations, but it is a doctrine sanctioned by the practice of war, and once hostilities are broken by one of the belligerent States, it can attack the other when and' where it pleases, although the responsibility respecting its decision as to the place of attack and the mode of attacking it will be left to history to judge." The writer passes to a consideration of the terms of Peace as embodied in the Protocol of.the 12th of August, 1898, his argiment being—this being a prelimin nary to his consideration of the responsibility for Spain's colonial loans—*that the sovereignty of Spain in Cuba passes, and in part has already passed, to the United States, either for themselves or for the people they have tried to liberate." This hypothesis carries with it "the acknow-of debt which weighs on the treasuries ledgment and payment of every sort

of Spain's colonies, and which are linked with properties and rights which she relinquishes." Thirty-five United States must assume these ges are devoted to proving that the debts, and a very good ex parte argument it is, while The holders of the bonds in question are significantly reminded that if the United States do not pay them, nobody will; for Spain to assume them would be an injustice to her other creditors. The concluding paragraphs of this section of the pamphlet are The United States have obtained an enormous indemnity of war, much superior to the expense they have incurred, in the islands of Porto Rice and the others which surround Cuba in the Western Sea, and under the title of protection, if only temporarily, though not limited by any precise period, the most valued island in the Atlantic Ocean passes into their possession; that is, the sovereignty of territories, in the greatest splendour of civilisation and prosperity, which comprise an area of 120,000 square kilometres, equivalent to the fourth of the total area of Spain itself.

Besides what we have said, we can add, in order to give a better idea of the importance which the results of the war have for the United States, that by them they realise, if they don't complete a political plan which fora long time they have been nursing; and it is not likely or is it probable that such a severe and humane rice, should turn their eyes away from right and morals, and refuse to recognise and pay debts which are sacred, either by putting themselves in Spain's place, or in the name of the Cuban people; debts the product of which every one knows has been employed for the benefit of the colonies which they are now about to possess, and in suppress sing the insurrections which the Americans themselves encouraged, though at the same time officially demanding their repression with obsolete compulsion.

Spain, despoiled of her Colonies, with all justice on her side, with her chivalrous conduct misinterpreted and maligned, may perhaps yield to force, the dominion of the conqueror may be carried to the extreme of exacting from her, the assumption of obligations she contracted in order precisely to avoid the struggle in which she has succumbed, but we who have watched this contest must not forget, that Spain is con-quoted but not dead, and that everything may be hoped for from that heroical race which in no very far removed date filled the new world with its gold, the old one with its heart and both with its blood, ever generous and noble.

Some twenty pages are then given to the consideration of " the legitimacy of the title which the Federal Government might invoke in its claims of the Sovereignty over a Bnited States have not conquered art of the Philippine Islands." 'The the islands, and their title to them! must therefore be looked for in the} Protocol, the third article of which runs: "The United States will occupy and hold the city, bay, and! harbour of Manila pending' the! conclusion of a treaty of peace which shall determine the control, dispo-} sition, and Government of the Philipines." This, it is argued, means; that the U. S. occupation of Manila Bay is only to be temporary, and "the disposition. of the Government of the Philippine Islands, to be de-! termined in the definitive treaty, refers exclusively to the Spanish Government." As the negotiators the definitive treaty have agreed to the sale of the Philippines for the equivalent of £4,000,000 sterling, this discussion is now only academic. But when the writer argues that because

was still the nominal" ruler of the Philippines, therefore these words mean that as far as re; the Philippines the function of the treaty of peace was limited to a discussion of how Spain should govern the islands in future, seems to us entirely unreasonable. To an ordinary person acquainted with French, English, or Spanish, this article means that it shall be determined in the treaty of peace how the Philippines shall be controlled, disposed of or governed in future; while the writer of this pam-blet insists that under it the United tates bound themselves to demand nothing more than "the temporary occupation of the city, bay, and har-hour of Manila, and the right to por" stipulate and determine in the final treaty of peace what is to be the system of government which Spain is to establish there in the future." And he adds:—

To end this matter, and entering in another order of ideas, we cannot but. state that this meaning is the only one which fits in with the policy of humane and civilizing intervention of the United States, for every one knows, and it has been stated again and again that the war with Spain has had no other object than to improve the political, civil and material existence oft inhabitants of her Colonies. We can thus understand that the United States should have reserved for themselves in that article the exclusive right of stipulating with the Metropolis, what her future government of the Island' was to be, in order that on establishing it, she should grant to her Colonies the greatest amount of liberty and autonomy compatible with the Sovereignty of the central government, and to this end the commissioners of both countries are to determine what the control, disposition and government of Spain over the political administration of the Philippine Islands, is for the future to be.

Then follows an argument to prove that the cession of Manila after the signature of the Protocol was null and void by international law, when ther the American forces were aware or not of the armistice, "and can give rise to no title or claim on the part of the American Republic, and that everything should be replaced in the same state as it was in on that day." And this very impartial pamphlet ends with an' attack on the United States for adopting a policy of expansion and hypocritically disguising their plans of conquest under "the idea, always grand and noble, of protecting the oppressed and helping the feeble." For seventy-six pages we read on in the hope that this pamphleteer at any rate—it is a very difficult thing for a foreign pampilstex: to do—was going to deny twisting the British Tion's tail, unself the subsidiary pleasure of

but the hope was in vain. First comes a paragraph on. page 77 Bower that has not protested against luting out that England isthe only the policy of the United: States, hile the concluding paragraphs, to

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account