The Archive · 1899

Chief Justice

Cmaxc Quas-kee v. Hat.

This was an action brought against H.

Hall, butcher of Shanghai to recover $631 for live stock supplied.

Mr. H. P. Wilkinson appeared for the plaintiff, and the defendant conducted his own case.

The petition and answer set forth that the claim owed its origin to similar circumstances to those in the numerous other cases_in which Mr. Hall has lately ap-Being that the camney was owing by a red as defendant, the defence as before

Chinese woman, uow deceased, in whose kinson in briefly opening the case said he had been served with a most extraordinary notice by Mr. Hall to Produce plnineife family doctor, and also rdship would form from that as the case Youngest fon, a baby in arms, His went on, some impression us to the defendant's state of mind.

Plaintiff gave evidence and admitted that certain payments had been made or were due to Mr. Hall and said that the amount actually due to him now was $474.

His Lordship reserved judgment, 27th January.

His Lordship delivered judgment in this case in the following terms:—The petition in this matter alleges that the sum of $631 was due from the defendant to the plaintiff and the defendant in his answer admitted all the paragraphs of the petition excepting the fourth, which was as follows There is now due and owing to the plaintiff xs part payment of siid live stock and on balance of accounts the sum of $631." At the hearing it appeared that in reality the plaintiff claimed the sum of $474. We have the evidence of the plaintiff that he supplied cattle to the defendant and that it was not paid for, and we than have the evidence of the accountant who produced the bonk showing the delivery of the cattle and the amounts which Were still unpaid. Against that in reality we have no evidence whatever. I have looked through the evidence m the case in order to make sure that I was not acting from any impression left on my} mind from the former cases, and to have only the evidence of the present coco before me in determining. I now come to! the conclusion that the plaintiff has made out his case and there will be judgment His Lordship replied that the hearing would not on account of the motion be postponed, but the chances were that the criminal cases set down for that day would occupy the whole time of the Court. He thought. for the convenience of the Court it would be advisable if the hearing was postponed until that day week. Mr. Browett would understand that the postponement was not occasioned through the present motion but the hearing would necessarily have to be put back. The defendant would have leave to file the answer he moved for.

Mr. Mann, in reply to a question addressed by "Mr. Browett, said he was prepared to put in the document at once.

hearing of the suit was accordingly adjourned till half-past ten on Friday next, defendant being ordered to pay the costs of the motion, which the Court assessed at $15.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account