The Archive · 1893

The French Mail Papers

(vor THE WEEK ENDING THE 2ND OF SEPT.)

The pronouncement of Sir Edward Reed that the Fictoria could not help caps when she was rammed, and that there are twelve other English battleships "flont, which would infallibly meet the same fate if they were injured in their ends had caused home. The Times says The confidence of the country cannot but be shaken by the very startling allegations of Sir Edward Reed concerning the insecurity in certain contingencies of a large number of ships at present in active service, Affirming that the disaster to the Victoria was due, not to some of the watertight, doors having been left open, bus to faults of construction which no closing of watertight doors would have remedied, Sit Halward Reed declared that no less than' twelve other ships were liable in similar circumstances to exactly the same catastrophe. If any of these were badly injured in their un armoured ends they would capsize." On the other hand, Sir Edward Harland, whose authority on such a point is not inferior to that of Sir Edward Reed, declared with equal confidence Victoria went to the bottom entirely on account of something being wrong with the bulkhead doors while Sir Ughtred Kay-Shuttleworth' virtually admitted that the Admiralty had not yet made up their minds why the Victoria went to the bottom. All s calculated not a little to disturb the public mind, Sir Ughtred Kay-Shuttleworth promises a full iry when the proper time comes for tating it, and acknowledges the res) ility of the Admiralty in the matter, but he does not tell us what kind of enquiry it is to be. It must, at any rate, be a public enquiry, at least og regards its results and the grounds on which they are based, and it must be such as to satisfy the public' mind. We must know whether the watertight doors of the Victoria were of the modern type deecgibed by Sir Edward Herland or of a more antiquated and less efficient type; whether their inefficient, Was the cause of the disaster, as Sir Edward pect, Harland aitirmed; or whether, on the other hand, Sir Edward Reed is right in saying, not only that the doors could not have been closed without bringing the work of the ship to a standstill; but that even if they had been closed the ship would still have capsized after receiving such a blow as that delivered by the Camperdown. We do not press for a hasty answer to these and other important questions involved, but it must be obvious that no enquiry which does not answer them fully will in the long run de satisfactory to the country. Two points must be thoroughly cleared up—one, whether the ships alleged by Sir Edward Reed to be unsafe are in reality as unsafe as he alleges, and incapable of being rendered safe by the appliances nominally provided for that purpose; the other, whether in the construction of modern warships due provision has been or can be made for protecting them as far as possible against the tremendous impact of the ram, The Daily News, of course, takes a leas alarmist view of the situation, It says:

Sir Edward Reed's views of naval construction differ from those which have been followed in the construction of the battleships: named. Those ships have ungrmoured ends, and when an admiral's error feads to ram: ming, and the loss of a ship, the opportunity of saying 'I told you so" is one which it would be more than human for an ex-naval Chief Constructor to resist. Sir Ughtred Kay-Shuttleworth's coolness was obviously shared by other speakers with authoritative voices on naval matters. At the same time it did not amount to complacency or indifference. The case of the Vitoria is to lead to. the strictest enquiry at the hands of naval experts. As to the general policy of the Admiralty, it was subjected to the usual discursive and contradictory criticism. Lord George Hamilton, Whose own programme is necessarily being carried out by his successors, found fault with the Government for building #0 many cruisers, But in doing that the Government are, accor ing to Mr. Wolff, a real expert, showing the first glimmering' of sense which he has yet perceived at the Admiralty. Critics of the Admiralty differ even more than doctors disagree.

We believe that it is in the service that the Victoria, and her ister-ship the Sans Pareil, were practically failures, and that they were imposing in more senses than one, The Times of the 30th Augurt has a very trenchant article on Mr, Gladstone's tended moving of the third readit Home Rule Bill, and we make two extracts from it If for once Mr. Gladstone could speak from the Palace of Truth in which a man sheds the successive layers of convention and says, not what he pretends to believe, or what he officially believes; or what he thinks he believes, but what he verily does believe, he would, beyond doubt, say things that would make the ears of the faithful to tingle. He would tell them that it is with sincere regret and reluctance that he finds himeelf driven to move the third reading of his Bill. He would point out that he never believed in Home Rule, and never believed in it less than just before he declared for it, but that something had to be done to patch up a majority which should keep him in power, and his best efforts had failed to discover any better device than this. He would dwell upon the int upon him by the defection of a large melancholy disappointment of his hopes and influential section of his followers, and upon the efforts he made in the cold shade of Opposition to discover some policy sufficiently distinct from that of the Unionist party to enable him to appeal with success for popular support. He would recall the painful inadequacy of the Newcastle mme for any jer purpose than that of acting as an auxiliary to Home Rule, and would demonstrate the hopelessness of any attempt to fix himself in Downing-street without the zealous assistance of the Nationalist party. Havin, thus explained why he had to bring for second edition of Home Rule, he would dwell with satisfaction upon the extremely comfortable manner in which the discussion of that question without the remotest pros-of its proximate solution has kept him in office and in congenial employment for meny months, It. was once hoped that by the time the third reading was reached the House of Lords would have become a promising enbject for track, We do not know whether thatugreeable illusion still lingers in the minds of the more childlike of Mr. Gladstone's followers, but it can hardly be very d ted in his own, The expedients resorted to in order to get the Bill through the Commons have given the Lords an inexpugnable position, The utterly shameless tergiversation of the Government the question of retention of Irish members is alone sufficient to spoil the campaign against the second Chamber once looked forward to with such keen delight, Englishmen may object to the government of English peers, but they object' much more strongly to the domination of Irish priests and the interference in all their domestic concerns of people representing illiterate Irish labourers and allied with the enemies of England, As for the cant about the Ho nds resisting the will of the people, it is too threadbare for further use at present. Mr. Gladstone has not paid he smallest Adtanton to te wil tricked them, deceived them, gegged them:

people. He has jockeyed the people,

and tyrannised over them by the most unworthy methods to which a politician can resort.

While the Daily News the following day gave the other side of the shield The magnificent speech in which the Prime ved the third reading of the Home in the House of Commons yesterday the debate, followed as it immediately was had agensibly depressing effect upon the rest of an unusually tedious harangue from the philosopher of Bodmm, Mr. Gladstone was great force, and the full Yellous voice resounded, as it seldom resounds such ie cheering has nowadays, in every corner of the House. No deen rurliament before as greeted the venerable Premier when he resumed his seat after an hour and a quarter of that inimitable eloquence which the seven months of this laborious Session have left undiminished and unimpaired. It may per-be thought that Mr. Gladstone need wave made no further reference to Sweden and Norway, and that the writings of Count Cavour might have been left to speak for themselves. But Gladstone had been challenged, and it is not his habit to leave a challenge unanswered, The Tories generally hi made capital out of Scandinavian and Mr, Chaplin has made free with the authority of Cavour, Without. Home Rule Sweden and Norway would have fought. Cavour's alleged condemnation of Home Rule consisted in advising this country to treat Ireland as she had treated obstacles out of the way, Mr. Gladstone pro-Canada, "Having cleared, these preliminary ceeded to deal with the justification for the "time closure" and with the manner in which the seventy-nine days devoted to the Bill before the third reading had substantially been spent. To the third and fourth clauses, which contain not the powers given by the but the restrictions and reservations imposed in it, three hundred and twenty-six amendments were put down. Of these a hundred and eighty-five, a modest proportion, were out of order. A hundred and forty-one were moved, and the time occupied in diseussing them was a hundred and ten hours. The speeches made in favour of the Bill have been four hundred and fifty-nine, the speeches against the Bill nine hundred and thirteen, or very nearly twice as many. But whereas fifty-seven hours and a quartet sufficed for the friends of the Government and for Ministers, themselves, a hundred and fifty-two hours and three-quarters, or nearly three times as many were occupied by the relevancy instead of length could have been made the test, the proportion would have been still more unfavourable to the Conservative party. Considering that the Reform Bill of 1831 occupied only forty-seven days and the Act of Union thirteen, the public will he able to appreciate the value of the assurance that the Bill has been pushed through the House of Commons with rash and headlong speed.

The feeling against the appointment of the Duke of Connaught, by his cousin the Duke of Cambridge, to the Aldershot command was very widespread, He is a good

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account