20th Oct.
Ture is a jest so old that itis included, we think, in the original "Joe Miller," of a Cambridge man who could swim, and who saw another man straggling in the river, and was asked why he did not jump in to his assistance. " But I have never been introduced to him," was the reply. This of course is a joke, but it is a joke that was closely copied in reality by the Shanghai Fire Brigade yesterday. At an early hour news reached the officers of the Brigade that the great Chinese Cotton Mill on the Point Road was on fire, and the assistance of the Brigade was requested. The alarm bell was not rang, however, and the Brigade was not called out, because the mill is outside the limits of the Settlement, and at the present moment this large mill and its godowns are a vast expanse of smoking and still flaming ruins, utterly destroyed by fir Several reasons are given why the Brigade was not called out yesterday. The Mill is outside the limits of the Settlements, and the Brigade, being a volunteer one, cannot be asked to go to put out a fire outside. With the wind that was blowing towards the river, the Brigade could have done no good' if they had gone; and there was no one at the Mill with a head on his shoulders, to authorise the Brigade to take charge of the fire, and take what measures might be thought necessary to combat the flames, 'I'he Mill belongs to Li Hung-chang and his friends, and as he las been and still is putting every possible obstacle in the way of, foreigners being allowed to import machinery for ginning, spinning, and weaving cotton, it would be absurd for foreigners to try to save the Mill which he is doing his best to make a monopoly, and which is interfering seriously with foreign trade. Ihe Mill, when it was insured, was insured in home offices, which contribute nothing to the cost of the Fire Brigade, and this immunity enables them to compete grievously with the local companies; and we cannot therefore be expected to put ourselves out of the way to save the Home Offices from Joss. 'I'hese and similar excuses are made for the action of the Chief Engineer in refusing to call out the Brigade. Ihe Chairman of the Municipal Council has no direct control over the Brigade, all he can do being to ask the Fire Commission to take action; the Chief Engineer is only responsible to the Fire Commission, and the District Engineers, however willing they may be to respond to such a pressing call for help, cannot act without orders from their Chief, if he is in Shanghai.
None of these excuses seem to us to hold water, and we believe this is the general opinion in the Settlement. The Mill is, or rather was, outside the limits; but there is a good road belonging to the Council leading right up to it; and while it is impossible to take the engines and trucks into the native city, or the native suburbs where there are no proper roads, there was no such difficulty in this case. There is no artificial water supply at the Mill, and no hydrants, but there is the river running along one-front of it, and at least the steam float might have been sent down, and might have saved the godowns full of cotton on the river front. As no attempt was made, no one can say with certainty that the Brigade could have done no good if it had gone down; and from what we know of the Chinese, we know perfectly well that they would have been only too glad to put the management of the operations in the hands of the staff of the Brigade, and to approve of any measures that the Chief Engineer might have taken. The argument that it is not our business to save the Home Offices from loss has been discarded long ago, We all of us benefit by the competition that the represent: tion here of the Home Offices duces, and the agents of those Offices are ratepayers, contributing to the revenues of the Settlement. No one thinks of asking, when a fire occurs in the Settlement, whether the property involved is insured in a local or a Home Office. But the argument that weighs most with some people is that drawn from the hostile attitude of Li Hung-chang towards foreign enterprise. At the first presentation this argument. does seem plausible, but further consideration will surely show that foreigners lost a great opportunity yesterday. One of our arguments for wishing to be allowed to start cotton manufactories is, that in so doing we are benefiting China as well as onrselves, and the last thing we should do is to confirm the great Viceroy in his belief that there is an ineradicable hostility between Chinese and foreigners. Even if the Fire Brigade could have done no good yesterday, it was a splendid opportunity to show the Viceroy that it is our habit if we can to return good for evil; that foreigners are not prepared to sit down and see a large mass of property destroyed without attempting to save it, because it Chinese. No doubt the Sermon on the Mount is not a collection of practical rules; but it is actually good policy to "do gond to them that hate you, and pray for them which despitefully use yon." Tt would have been a most valuable object lesson to the Chinese officials, if they had seen the flower of the youth of Shanghai working to save the property of those who had put themselves into an attitude of hostility to them, and doing it for no possible direct advantage to themselves, and not to ward off any danger to the Settlements, but just to show that good will which we are sure animates nine-tenths at least of the Brigade, who, we are certain, would willingly have gone to the Fire if the Chief Engineer had ordered the bell to be rung. It was a great chance. thrown away, and we regard the matter as so serious that we shall be glad to hear that the Municipal Councils have asked the Fire Commission to explain why it was thrown away, and on whom rests the responsibility for its having been let slip.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.