The Archive · 1893

An Incident of the French Blockade of Bangkok

In reprinting the correspondence between the Earl of Dudley and Lord Rosebery which has been published in The Times under the heading of "Her Majesiy's ngkok," the Bangkok: Times Although we are not in a position to give an official version of this incident, we believe that the following recount of what occurred will be found correct French Ad. miral Hum Chang, when issuing a second blockade of the Gulf of Sinm altering' in substantial points that previously issued by Captain Reculoux of the Forfait, communicating the new notice to the Osptain of the Pallas, gave it clearly and distine'ly to be understood that the blockade ied equally to men-of-war as to mer-ips," 'Three days' g mercisnut ships to leave the Sismese included within the blockade limits, and the firat: inference was that the foreign gun-Dents ut Bangkok were thus notified to clear out of the Menam within the pre scribed time, That it was the first inten: tion, or rather wish, of Admiral Hamann that the foreign gunboats should fallow the example of all the merchant ships nnd take their de der te produce a greater moral effect upon the Siamere Guvernmut, is more than probable, The am-ing of the Admiral's notice lent interpretation, ut least momentarily, but Captain MacLend, the senior naval commander of the English warships here, bad the point promptly cleared up, ug the most eff nes the meaning of his declaration by infor ug Jum that sinder no eivenmste the "Linnet" leave Bani This was also, we believe, the view and determina. tion of the British Minister, Captain Tones, V.C. Pending advices from home with rogerd to the irregular, vexat and illegal © paci jo declared by Aduiral Bu trary to th pledges given by M. Develle to the English Government that such x declaration should not be made for at least two days Later thu the date this step was taken by the! French Admiral on his own responsibility (and, na there la, giod reason to believe tuan!), Captain MacLend doubtless merely ary to the orders of his own Govern:

deemed it only pradent—perhaps a ional reasons which we to take the Pallas, nderatand, was only ili commander after ig Arrangements promptly any the British view of the arbitrary, and, unauthorised action of Admiral Homans Had Cuptai he might vitiier lave precipitated a war between Englind and France, or, as Frenel Adu in the East, treated the Frevch Government with contemptuous indifference, the Inter might have declared war against Siam, resulting in further French aggression upon this country, xnd bringing bout complications the end which it was impossible to foresee. The real fact of the matter is that the British Government was deceived by the promises and pledges given by that of France, which in turn was disobeyed and deceived—because we can believe nothing else of x serious and honourable Govern ment—by its own officers and officials. In the confusion created by the Eng-Government's telegrams, based upon Paris declarations, and the precipitate action of the French Admiral, the course taken by the E> senior naval officer on this station was, all circumstances considered, in our opinion the best and most correct that could have been pursued. If ho erred at all—and we can discover no error—the "error" on the side of prudence, an "error" limited by the nature of the crisis to the few hours required for an exchange of telegrams with England, With such momentous issues at stake, momentary prudence " at least "was the better part of valour." Public and private telegrams received here as to the undertaking given by the French ment to that of Evgland with to the blockade fully confirmed cial advices which it was understood were received at the time by the Siamese Government and by the representatives of England, Declarations made in the British Parliament and in the English Press also subsequently confirmed the cause of the cent ich is the true origin of the ut to which we have re-/ ferred, we believe, enabled to analyse and explain it with almost complete accuracy, from the reliable Anta now placed in our hands, Lord Rosebery considers the incident as one of "his torical" value, or rather that a correct explana is n matter for historical Asan episode having a most mpertant bearing upon the disputed ques-of pacific blockade" the incident ich wider application and greater iguificanee than the limited view expressed by Lord Rosebery, and we believe that our narration of the facts, ax well na venture to make, will prove not only " historically accurate," but of considerable interest frum the standpoint of international Inw.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account