Shanghai, 11¢h July. Before Joux Goopxow, Esq., U.S. Consul-General (President); De. Kyarre, Acting Consul-General for Germany and P. L. Warrex, Esq. H.B.M.'s Acting Consul-General.
Browerr v. Musiciran Couscit.
This case arose out of an action between —which was tried before the Court last year, judgment being given in May. Mr. F. Ellis (Messrs. Browett and Ellis) appeared for the Plaintiff, and Mr. Hanson (Messrs. Dowdall, Hanson and MacNeill) for the Council.
The petition of the Plainti was as follows 1.—The Plaintiff is a British Subject, and a Solicitor of Her Britannic Majesty's Suie Court for Chiva and Japan, and resides 14, Babbling Well Road, Shanghai, in the Empire of China.
pa (he Defendants are the Council for the Foreign Community of Shanghai aforesaid, elected by the Ratepayers of Shanghai aforesaid in pursuance of the powers vested in them by the Land Regulations for the Foreign Settlements of Shanghai aforesaid north of the Yangkinepang.
3.—The Plaintiff has been since the 16th day of January 1838, and still is, the registered proprietor of all that piece or parcel of fand situated within the boundaries of ground set apart for the location of Foreign Heaters at Shanghai aforesaid and known and registered in the books for the Registration of Land kept at the United States Consulate General at Shanghai aforesaid as lot number 112, the title deed whereof is also numbered —The Plaintiff is desirous of inclosing by means of a fence the northern portion of the said lot.
5.—The Plaintiff has applied to the De-fondant for a permit to erect such fence but the Defendants have refused and still refuse to grant such permit, The Plaintiff therefore humbly prays this honourable Court 1.—That the Defendants may be ordered to grant forthwith to the plaintiff such permit as aforesaid, and, The Plaintiff further prays for an order 2.—That on the Defendants failing to grant shall be at liberty and have the full right and sac permit as aforesaid that he the plainti power to erect such fence without obtaining the permission of the Defendants.
3.—That the Defendants may be ordered to pay the costs of this action.
4—That the Plaintiff may have such further or other relief as this honourable Court may think fit.
The answer of the Defendants was as follow:
1.—They admit the allegations contained Paragraphs 1,2, 4y and 9, ofthe Petition,—They admit the allegations contained in paragraph 3 except that they say that on the 16th day of January 1888 the plaintiff became the owner of only part of the lant which is now included in the Consular title deed for U.S. lot 112. The plaintiff acquired the remainder of the land namely the north. ern portion of the said lot in the year 1890.
&—The land originally included in the title deed for the said for No. 112 was first acquired from the native owners in the year 1802 and the portion acquired by the plaintiff in the year 1890 and now included in the lot was beach ground the year 1862 and. therefore became on its acquisition by the plaintiff subject to public uses under Regula. tion V of the Land Regulations of 1854 and can only be held by him subject to such uses.
4.—The enclosure by " fence of the north: ern portion of the sai Tot a proposed by the plaintiff will seriously interfere with if not totally prevent. the exercise by the public of all public rights over the northern portion of the lot and' the defendants claim therefore that they were right in refusing to grant a permit for such fence.
Defendants therefore pray that the petition of the plaintiff may be dismissed with costs.
Mr. Ellis in opening the case for the plaintiff said—May it please Your Honours, the nature of the relief as' will he seen by the petition asked for by the plait from the Court is an order to defendants to. grant to the plaintiff a permit to erect & fence portion of Lot 112, of wi registered proprietor and in the event of the defendants failing to grant such permit that he, the plaintiff, be at liberty to erect such' fence without obtaining the permission of the defendants. 3 the defendants practically adit all the allegations set out in the pinintift's petition, it will not be necessary to examine Mr. Browett as to these facts, but I shall have to call Mr, Browett to prove certain corres pondence which passed between hin and the defendants, the outcome of which are the present "proceedings. Now, your in order to enable you to' ful-[hope to appreciate the argu:
ich will be offered for your tion it will be necessary for me to refer very briefly to the points raised and decided by this Court in a last suit_where the present parties were' the parties und where the land which formed the subject-matter of that suit formed again the subjectanatter of this suit. February of ast year a petition was filed by the plaintiff against the defendants in which he prayed for a perpetual order and injunction to restrain the defendants from entering upon the land or any part or portion of it, and also from dumping, deposit ing or otherwise dealing with yarbnge thereon. To this the defendants made answer that having for over 20 years interruptedly used this land form gupba yard they were not now trespassing the denied that the use of the yrowud garbage yard constituted wuisumoes's ffetly, they maintained that the laud the
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.