The Archive · 1899

The Browett Foreshore Case

To the Editor of the Nonra-Cutsa Darcy News, Sin,—Judging from the quest Mr. Mayne (the M. C. Engineer) the clause in the judgment which you have quoted more that once, it appears that, if the Municipal Council had only drawn elaborate plans for a public jetty or had put forward a scheme for widening the Ghekiang Road Bridge, the judgment would have been the reverse of what it was and would undoubtedly have been'in the favour of the Coun It is possible with the numerous more urgent calls on the "Councils attention and pocket that neither of these schemes has yet taken shape, bat with the "awakening" that is going on around us, it does not require any great prescience to see that the particular lot of ground which Mr, Browett claims on behalf of his native client, I believe, is the one point on the Soochow Creek which is most likely to be the must required for public purposes. It is on the right side of the Creek for a public jetty, it is the nearest point of discharg+ to the Railway station it is on the best road from the Railway station to the native city, and when the Railway is completed to chow and Chinkiang it must be the best point for passengers and freight from all the surrounding neighbourhood to be landed and loaded to nnd from the Railway. Assuming for one moment that the judgment was founded on there being no Municipal schemes in evidence, I maintain that the judgment is wrong.

Tt is hardly to be expected, however able the men themselves may be, that three gentlemen who hare comparatively recently arrived can know all the necessities of a place like Shanghai, and although we feel that the judziment has been somewhat hasty and unconsidered we can hardly blame them for taking a superficial view of the ease, when their multitudinous duties are taken into account. Their judgment was according to their lights, but at the same time I should be very pleased to sign a petition for re-hearing the ease, when T trust that a judgment more in accord with the traditions of the place, with the Fights of the public to the use of foreshore or beach ground, and with the acknowledged reading of Article VI of the Regulations would be given.

Tt would be a public wrong if Mr. Browett or his client were left in peaceful possession of Lot.112 simply because the Engineer of the Municipal Council had not received instructions to draw a plan for a jetty or for a wider bridge across the Soochow Creek.

Lam, ete., 'A Rareraver.

19th July.

To the Editor of the

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account