The Archive · 1900

Empress of India

mail of the 16th of March. the date min. He was a to make extensir mew line of roads. He quoted dictionaries to show that "extension" means "stretehtration: continua id that to tion first enlargement nin length." ake the Regu th prov shall be ade for the extension) and i se oot the ninnber of the lines of road at present Taid down. By no rule for the construction of stitutes or any other written documents can such an saterpretation be justified and Tam brought face to face with this: th the words in the first and operative part of the Regulation are not to be reconciled with the i ud. choose which words Twill to The s begins with the words to this end, ud is clearly therefore an_explanas the means by which that which precedes it shall Lo carried out, Tr the anted by the first portion.

fore Of opinion trio construction of the firs mrt of that it relates te. f lines of roads laid down in ING9 and to no others. Upon this ground 1 dismiss the titis pot itis That ines the In coming to s ne doubt lad in his wi hip that it seemed to be to Mr, McMurray to! it make him give up his land without payment, and he accepted maxim in, it anay he added, whic not promote but de In estimating the word "extension" as they do, the Privy Council are certainly confirmed by ordinary commercial usage. If a firm of nis who had previously confined themselves to export trade were to announce that they were about to extend their business, they would certainly not be expected to confine themselves to increasing their trade in exports, but the word would be held to legitimately cover their entrance into the import trade or their adoption of other new branches of busin:

Their Lordships go on to say The happily expressed proviso at the end of that part of the Regulation which has been set out above, subject of remarks arn pointed aly defined meant ked out on the map, as the rident contends. all the preceding at the provisions would be nul ied. It was not necessary in that cas which related to the preservation of beach lands from build.

true the proviso with Nex has it been necessary f preme Court to construe it in this Ir must be construed now; and wu as the Regulation is, their Lordships do not, after the careful sifting which it ived during the argument, feel ous difficulty about it. They huid at the roads already are roads tnentioned in the whole of the preceding part of the Regulation, including the extensions or authorised new roads for which express and specific pro-afternoon by the A MAUL leaves to-morrow for Europe by the MALS. Yura.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account