The Archive · 1900

A Stamping Case

Angus McNeil, an A.B, of the barque Orealla, was brought up on remand changed ith cutting and wounding another seaman named John Rio, on board that vessel on the night of the 19th instant.

The complainant said there had been a row in the forecastle on Tuesday night and he heard defendant call a man named Green a foul name. He remonstrated with defendant for his langange, and he then drew his knife and stabbed complainant four times in the stomach, Complainant fell down, bleeding.

Defendant—This min interfered after Green had knocked me about.

Complainant said he had only told him not to call Green such wames as ho did. That was all he knew about it.

Captain Tyres put in a certificate from Dr. Burge stating that Rio's wounds were slight incised ones and not serious.

Alfced Green, A.B., on the Orealla, stated that shortly after 11 p.m. on Tuesday defendant "got on" to him and they started fight Witness was getting the best of it, when defendant drew his with the intention of stabbing him, Rio told him he was no good to deaw his knife whereupon defendant called him a bad name and stuck the knife into him four times. Defendant took off his boots and was creeping about the deck when he was put in irons, Witness had aroused the second mate who arrested defendant. It was witness who had knocked defendant about causing the injuries on his face. Defendant was struck on the neck when arrested as he tried to draw his knife.

Defendant said, in answer to his Worship, that he was' pretty well on in drink at the time and Green knocked him about for no cause whatever.

Green said defendant had called him a foul name and when he asked him why he had done so he said he did not know. Green then struck him. He (Green) had had a little drink.

Robert Wilson, boy on the Orealla, stated that Green was singing' when defendant abused him, He bore out the story of Rio and Green as to the use of the knife.

Defendant said they had had a fight that night and he had to defend himself. All could say was that he was the worse for liquor. He could not t: ll the cause of the row, hut Green began it. He admitted drawing his knife, but stid it was in self-defence. After being put in irons he had been grossly abused, kicked and beaten. He believed some of his ribs and bones had been broken.

Constable Brun said a doctor had seen defendant and pronounced mo bones to have been broken: He had only flesh wounds and scratches, His Worship said—This was evidently a drunken disturbance of a rather serious nature, and you, McNeil, know perfectly well that you had no right to draw knife on your shipmates, "There is, however, not sufficient prima facie evidence for me to send you for trial on the more serious charge. For the assault you must go to prison for two weeks with hard labour.

Shanghai, 22nd June.

R. v. Praxt.

F. Plant, a seaman from the ship Howard D. Troop was charged with having been drunk and disorderly on Broadway yesterday.

Sergeant Gibson stated that he saw the defendant at 11.30 a.m., yesterday drunk on Broadway, he was rolling all over the Sidewalk and fell against a window, breaking it. On witness arresting him, ho became violent. He butted witness with his head and tried to strike him. Witness had to hold him down till assistance came. Defendant had been before the Court on the 19th instant on a similar charge.

Defendant, in answer to His Worship said he had nothing to say.

His Worship sent defendant to prison for 10 days with hard labour, saying he knew well he had no right to resist the police. The cost of the window, 30 cents, and 25 cents for food, would be deducted from his pay, and if the ship sails before his sentence is finished he is to be put on board.

R. v, Suave.

R. Slade, who had been before the Court the previous day for drunkenness, was similarly charged to-day.

P. C. Stromquist deposed that at 8.40 p.m., yesterday, some Chinese complained to him that a European was making a disturbance in Nanzing Road. He went there and found defendant drunk in a shop and unable to take care of himself. Witness arrested him and he went quietly to the station.

His Worship said he had given defendant a chance on the previous day and this time he should go to prison for 5 days. The cost of his food at the police station would be deducted from his pay and if the ship sailed sooner ho would be put on board.

Shanghai, 23rd June, R. ©, Dawsoy, W. G. Dawson was charged with having been drunk and incapable un the Tsingpoo Toad on the 2nd instant.

Chinese P. C. 266 deposed that ho found defendant lying asleep on the rond. He tried to rouse him but failed, and Ind to get the aid of riesha coolies' to take him to the Hongkew Police Station, Defendant, in reply to his Worship, said he had nothing to say. He had had nothing treat for some days. Yesterday he met some friends, had some drink, and it took hold of him.' He hid nothing to do and nowhere to go. He was a marine engineer and had applied to the Consul for relief, but was refused.

Mr. River, of the Shipping Office, said that defendant had been relieved by the ofice, he being sent to the Sailors' Home and $3 being expended on him, Defendant never came near the office to give.a receipt and they were put to much trouble when sending their returns home.

Defend: nt said he understood the money was a gratuity or he would have returned it, finding employment at that time.

Mr, Rivero said the money was gratuitously given, but the office had to send in its returns' to the Board of Trade. Defendant never gave them notice at all that_he had got employment.

His Worship said that, as defendant had been treating this thing' with indifference

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account