21th Aug.
'THe home journals will soon be coming out to us filled with articles on the lessons of the war by experts of all kinds, those who believe themselves to have been born experts, those who have achieved expertism, and those who have had expertisim thrust upon them. 'I'wo-thirds of this at least will be twaddle, but it will not do mach harm, because it will be contradictory twaddle, A civilian must feel something of the traditional fool who rashes in when he attempts to criticise the operations of a war of which he has actually seen nothing at all, but there are some things that strike him, apart from the technical details which only one who has achieved expertism should treat, which he inay perhaps be allowed to-set down, and yet escape the charge of presumption.
In the July issue of the Pall Mall Magazine, before the naval action off go, Mr. H. W. Wilson, a frequent writer on naval matters, said The Latin and the Anglo-Saxon, so often in conflict in the past, are meeting once more in battle, and issues the most mo-montons hang upon the conduct of the combatants. The war between the United States and Spain is a copy on a very reduced scale and with some slight modifications of " war between England and France. It is not my purpose in this article to work our s detailed compari I can only suggest it. The great British superiority in battleships and un armoured cruisers against France is faithfully re-reduced in the American navy as against spain. The great French advantage in armoured cruisers finds its parallel in the Spanish navy. Even in torpedo craft the numerical equality which exists between England apd Fiance is repented. with some correctness in the two combatant navies. Thus all conditions are fayour-I of our race; upon the con-ital Sampson and Commodore pends not merely the honour of the Schley's officers and blue-jackets de-Inited States, but the very existence of the British empire. If the men who are hourly expecting battle in the Caribbean falter, if they show any want of courage or sailormanship—which God forbid—then let us be certain that an attack will be delivered upon England by her enemies, who will tary yqualition of the Anglo-Saxon have conclude, and not unjustly, that the m clined under the depressing burden of civilisation. And as this is the greatest problem to be settled in the war, so we shall hope and pray that our race may emerge with glory from the test.
Mr. Wilson's comparison is vitiated by the obvious fact that while there is very little difference between the American and English navies, there is really a vast difference between the French and Spanish navies, in favour of the former. It is a common thing nowadays to hear remarks made on the decadence of the In ces; if there is anything this decadence, it touches the French navy, for the ty, we take it, of French sailors are not of the Latin race; they are Bretons, fine sailors and gued. fighting; Much has been written, very chivalrously by the Americans, of the courage of the "Spanish sailors, but they did no real fighting whatever; does any one suppose that French sailors would have behaved as Cervera's men did? 'I'he latter devoted their whole energies to running away; they fired off their guns indeed as they ran, but they never looked to see whether they were hitting anything, and two fine torpedo-catchers built at Clydebank were destroyed by a small anarmonred yacht, the Corsair, now the U.S.S. Gloucester, commanded by Lieut. Wainwright, Admiral Cervera allowed after he was made prisoner that he knew it was hopeless to attempt to escape the American fleet, but he obeyed his orders to make a dash from Santiago; a French Admiral in such a case would have told his captains each to engage an American ship and do as much damage as he could, even if he were bound to be sunk in the end, This is what poor old Admiral ling wanted to do when he was cornered at Weihaiwei by the Japanese, but he had strict orders from Li Hung-chang not to go out. It is undoubtedly satisfactory, as Mr. Wilson says, that the enemies of England should conclude that the military qualities of the Ans have not declined under the depressing burden of civilisation; but after all we do not suppose our enemies had many illusions on that score. We are always doing too much fighting all over the world. It is true that when the war began there were many who thought that the United States were so unprepared that in the beginning Spain would have some successes at sea; dut this opinion was not shared by any who knew what the Spanish navy really was, and who were acquaint ed with the way in which the ships of the United States are officered and manned. In fact, the naval operations of the war have not taught us much that was new, though they lave em-sised what was previously surmised, that you can ly have too many quick-firing guns on your ships, and that the torpedo is a vastly overrated instrument of war.
One very encouraging fact emerges from the accounts of the fighting round Santiago; that when it comes' to hard fighting there' is little to choose between regulars and vol teers. Our special correspondent at Manila has told us how fine a showing the volunteers under Merritt have made there. The standing army. of the United States is so smalt, that the Government in making up its expeditions had to rely largely on volunteers, and as the great Civil War ended too long ago for its veterans to "gird on their old swords," these volunteers have never had any more experience of actual war than our own volunteers at howe. Yet the long extract from the Argonaut which will be found in another column shows how well they fought, what few mistakes they made, rough-riders dul indeed yet. into an ambush, as regulars might well have done, as it was through
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.