The Archive · 1900

The False Step

To the Editor of the "Nontu-Cmtsa Dany News."

Sin, ~The principal argument Holliday advances in his letter of ves against. the proposed illuminations and festivities would appear to lie in 1 is fear that the Chinese may size the opportunity to create a disturbance, Apart from the fuct that the consensus of native ant foreign opinion is totally opposed to such a view, the fact should be borne in mind that the decision to hold these festivities has been published by the Council, ind its abandonment owing to Mr. Holliday's reasons is calculated to produce the very results which inspire him with nervous forebodings.

Putting aside the propriety of his letter as coming from an officer of the S.V.C. it is perhaps pertinent to remind Mr. Holliday that only a few years ago he made a speech, the exact terms of which I do not reovllect, adversely criticising the Council of the day for having abandoned a certain intention in the face of evident indications on the part of the Chinese to croute trouble.

Leaving out of consideration the question of the advisability of the Council's decision regarding the proposed celebration at the present time, it appears to many that Mr. Holiday's letter is un unfortunate one from first to last, especially lasts Tam, ete., 27th August.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account