The Archive · 1898

Nors. Cana Dany News

Sim,—It it more than a week since you had occasion to refer, in your leader, to the Senior Consulship. The subject was shortly afterwards discussed in the Shanghai Mercury's issue of the 20th instant and subsequently adverted to ina letter to that paper with the endeavour to explain Senhor Valdez's acceptance of the post of Doyen. Since then, however, there has been no allusion to the subject, no reference whatever to the opinions of the Press in the matter, not the shadow of a protest! But why......

There are undoubtedly many ways of looking at the question, and a great deal has already been said and written in connection with it. It remains to be seen, however, whether the statements publish ed so far can reasonably be upheld on the ground that Senhor Valde:'s occupancy of the post should be prejual the interests of the community. This is the only basis on which discussion can be conducted, and you will, I trust, allow me to make a few remarks in regard to it.

From the opinions emitted by the Press it would appear that that the only persons qualified for the place are the representatives of Great Britain, Germany, or the United States. It would therefore follow that in the event of the retirement of a Senior Consul (supposing him to be one of the three) the ion would devolve on the representative of one of the two remaining Powers, were he even the second most recently recently appointed Consul-General in Shanghai with only a limited experience of Far Eastern matters. He would accordingly take precedence of every other Consul-General (whoever to may be) who through seniority in office col more intimate acquaintance with government ways in China would be emi-nantly more fitted for the post.

You further contend when communicating with Ministers in Peking, on community matters, the fact that representations come through the Consul-General for Portugal, as Doyen, cannot fail _to lessen their weight in the eyes of Native Authorities. It would aphowever, that any cemniunication to Ministers in Peking, being addressed, as is generally the case, to the Doyen of the Diplomatic Body there, is by him transmitted to the Tsungli Yamen. From that moment the affair becomes entirely a matter between the Doyen at Peking and the Chinese officials; and surely it is not the senior Minister who would allow petty considerations to affect the interests at stake. Matters would, it seems, be arranged and settled between them irrespective of the channel through which Fepresntations from Shanghai are sent so long as they emanate from the Consular Tt is open to doubt whether the matter is actually viewed in the same light by the Consular Body here. That the post of Doyen should, in preference, be held by the representa of countries having

and even desirable in normal times, but, larger interests in China, may be politic nevertheless, the question will present itself whether the tide of events may not render its occupancy by the Consul-General of a first-class Power subject of anything but contentment to rival Powers? Would the representative of a smaller nation not be less likely to find his immediate interests in conflict with the discharge of his duties as Senior Consul In conclusion, I might refer to certain statements for which your contemporaries are responsible which could be dealt with here, but it seems preferable not to dwell upon declarations which have clearly sprung from @ biassed point of view. I vill pass them over in silence.

It can only be regretted that any paper should have ventured to pnt forward a suggestion of the possibility of either the Chamber of Commerce or Municipal Council requesting the Doyen to resign.

Who unbroken harmony which has, so far, characterised the relations betwoon the Consular Body, the Municipal Council, and the Chamber of Commerce has been guarantee that Foreign interests are safely looked after. Would it not be a pity that the Bodies should be at variance on a point which, after all, is very well as it stands Thanking you for publishing the above in your valuable paper, Tam, ote., Impenitus.

25th September.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account