The Archive · 1900

The British Minister During the Siege of Peking

Racing some recen, respondence in your vo'umns discussing ce conduct of the British Minister during Siege of the Legations at Peking brought to recollection the answer to a question given by two non-Britishers shortly after the relief. The question was put with the purpose of eliciting information as to the general conduct of the defence. Mr. A.'s reply was to the effect that early in the siege there was much dissatisfaction expressed with Sir Claude's management of affairs, but that toward the end he gave more satisfaction. On another occasion a similar query was addressed to Mr. B., who replied to the effect that in the earlier stages Sir Claude performed his military duties with much ability, but that towards the end there was a great deterioration observable. Messrs. A. and B. are both fairly intelligent men, both were actively engaged in the defence, as civilians, they had equal opportunity for observation and for hearing the opinions by others, lay and expert. Evidently the personal predilections of the observers are an important factor in the equation, and when all is said the facts remains that under the. command of Sir Claude Macdonald the British Legation sustained the siege until its relief under circumstances unexampled in the history of beleaguered gar-risens, That ho received the most valuable help alike from his own nationals and from others, from soldier, marine and civilian has been made abundantly evident. To give. due praise. to.each when so much praise is duo, it is nob necessary, happily to detract from any. The glory is enough to go round and to give each an abundant share. For once, too, the world is unanimous in its praise of the whole body of defenders, making no exception for the simple reason that without exception every man and woman. did his or her duty, quietly and uncomplainingly, steadily and daringly. Honour them to whom honour due, and surely the honour of the defence of the Legation in Poking is duo to all who had a share in its dangers.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account