27th Sept. TuE following are the terms in which the Transvaal Crisis was alluded to in the Speech of the Queen on the prorogation of Parliament have received a petition from.a considerable number of my subjects residing in the South African Republic praying for my assistance to obtain the removal of grievances and disabilities of which they complain. The position of my subjects in the South African Republic is inconsistent with the promises of equal treatment on which my grant of internal independence to that Republic was founded, and the unrest caused thereby is.a constant source of danger to the peace and prosperity of my dominions in South Africa. Negotiations on this subject with the Government of the South African Republic have been entered into and arg till proceeding."
It was remarked at the time as a very significant fact that the Queen was not made to express any hope that there would be a successful issue to the negotiations. Lord Salisbury himself, whom no one accuses of being anxious to plunge the country rashly into war, accent tuated the tension by saying in the House: "We have put our hands to the plough, and we will not draw back." Mr. Labouchere and Mr. A. J. Wilson regard the impending war—it is actually imending though we still trust it will averted—as the malign effort of Mr. Chamberlain to impress on the country a full sense of his own importance; but Mr. Chamberlain has shown that he fally realises the gravity of the situation, and we do not believe that even he, even if he is as devoid of scruples as his enemies declare him to be, would lightly provoke a war in South Africa. On the 8th of May 1896 Mr. Chamberlain said in the House of Commons:-—
"A war in South Africa would be one of the most serious wars that could possibly be waged. It would be a long war, a bitter war, anda costly war, and, as I have pointed out already, I believe generations would hardly be able to blot it out; and to go to war with President Kriiger to enforce upon him reforms in the internal affairs of his State, in which Secretaries of State, standing in their place, have repudiated: all right of interference—that would be immoral."
Later on in the same year Mr. Chamberlain said "What is the alternative policy which the honourable member would have put forward? We know what it would be. He would have sent an ultimatum to President Kriger that, unless these reforms, which he would have specified, were granted by a particular day, the British Government would inter-fore by force, and then he would have come here and he would have asked the House for a vote of credit of £10,000,000 or £20,000,000—it would not matter which particularly—and would send an army of 20,000 men at least to force President Kriiger to grant reforms in a State with which we have pledged ourselves repeatedly—not this Government but previous Governments by the mouths of successive Secretaries of State—that we would have nothing todo. That is his policy. It is not my policy, and it never will be."
'James Russell Lowell says "A merciful Providunce fashioned us holler purpose that we might our principles swaller It can hold any quantity on em, the belly can, An' bring em up ready for use like the pelican."
Mr. Chamberlain has swallowed a good many of his principles since he began his political career, but that he would cheerfully gulp down principles that he cnuncinted only three years ago, without very good and strong reasons, we do not believe. His description of a war in South Africa is not a bit over-coloured. The Boers with their allies can put, we are assured, over 90,000 men into the field, and they have a vast number of sympathisers in Cape Colony. These men are, no doubt, loyal to the English rule, and they know that they are treated with perfect. fairness in the English colony in which their lot is cast, while the Englishmen and others are treated witl the grossest unfairness by the Dutch in the Transvaal but when the fight begins, if it does unhappily begin after all, we cannot be surprised if it is difficult for them to ignore altogether the ties of blood. The great fear is not for the resent; we can easily send enough force to crush the Boers; what is really to be feared is the legacy of hatred and distrust that the war will leave.
We endeavoured to show the other day in our notice of Mr. Spencer Wilkinson's little treatise what the cruz of the situation is. There are 100,000 British and 80,000 Americans and Continental Europeans who pay nine-tenths of the taxes and have made the South African Republic the rich little country it now is, and who yet have no political rights, as against the less than 80,000 Boers who rule over them. They have many grievances, but the chief one, the one that dominates all the others, is tha denial of the franchise and representation. This denial is in direct contravention of President Kriiger's promises in 1881, when their autonomy was - restored to the Boers, as the following extract shows "The Commissioners were Sir Hercules Robinson (President), Sir Evelyn Wood, and Sir Henry de Villiers. They held several conferences with Mr. Kriiger and other Boer leaders. At one of these conferences the following conversation took place "President—Before annexation, British subjects complete freedom of trade throughout the Transvaal! Were they on the same footing as the citizens of the Transvaal "Mr. Kriiger—They were on the same footing us the burghers; there was not the slightest difference, in accordance with the Sand River convention.
"President—I presume you will not. object to that continuing "Mr. wger—No. "There will be equal protection for everybody.
"Sir K, Wood—And equal privileges "Mr. Kriiger—We make no difference, so far as burgher rights wre concerned. There may perhaps be some slight difference in the ease of a young person who has just come into the country."
In 1884, when the second London Convention was framed, any. settler in the Transvaal could become a Burgher who had five years' residence and paid a small fee. Gradually the law has been altered so as to make it practically impossible for any settler to become a Burgher. Averse as we must be to a war, fully we must realise its dangers and its horrors, fur the sake of the whole of South Africa and the whole British Empire we cannot allow British subjects to be treated in the Transvaal as inferior to the Boers, while we allow the Dutch full equality in our own colonies. We have quoted before from the New York Nation, and w quote from it because it is moderate, anti-jingo, peace-loving journal, not especially Angloph Tt says in its issue of the 17th ul Transvaal great grievances, which it is undoubtedly the duty of the English Government to see re-
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.