The Archive · 1898

Miscellaneous Articles

FASHODA

19th Oct.

Ir is very satisfactory to be assured by all the recent telegrams, including the one we publish this morning, that been allowed to cause any serious the dispute about Fashoda has not

friction between France and England. In the Investors' Review of the 16th ult. Mr, Wilson writes Asa strategical move, the French march on*Fashoda, assuming it to have taken place, can only be looked upon as a piece of foolish bravado, and we are firmly convinced that sensible Frenchmen will so regard it. That any serious friction should arise between their Government and ours over the episode we altogether refuse to believe. And we say all this as being amongst those who have most strenuously opposed the whole of our own recent ohoy of conquest in Africa. Its success as increased our responsibilities to an extent the nation as yet by no means realises, but that makes no difference whatever to the temper it will display should another Power now seek to appropriate any of the fruits of our victory. Hair-splitting about our abdication in favour of King Leopold's Congo State, and his gifts of what was not yet in fact his own to the French, will count for nothing in popular estimation now that Mahdism is destroyed. We most earnestly trust, therefore, that the Marchand expe-ill he quietly recalled, for there is in all the Nile basin worth a quarrel betiveen England and France.

The danger is past, if it ever existed, directly it is realised, as it must be by all sensible men both in France and England, that " there is nothin in all the Nile basin worth a quarrel between England and France." Asa matter of fact, it must be something very serious indeed that would be worth a quarrel between France and England. When we printed the other day a Reuter's telegram the effect of which was that France must give way in this matter, some of our Frenel friends were inclined to consider the proposition as altogether too arrogant, as too regardless of the French nights in the matter. But really, apart from arrogance or British prejudice, the French have no rights in the Nile valley. As the Saturday Review explains in its issue of the 17th ultimo Our claim to occupy Fashoda is unusually good, The town belonged to the Egyptian Government, its trade was organised and its Governor appointed by General Gordon when he administered the Equatorial Provinces, and it was inevitable that it should be reoccupied by the Egypti Government when the Soudan was recon-Gonbe that such would be the course pur-nored. There has never been the slightest

sued, and the French Government has been frequently informed of our intention. Nor hus the French Government ever denied that Fashoda was as much a part of Egypt as Khartoum; it has merely ignored the matter in the hope that some turn of events might bring an advantage. As diplomatists the French were quite: justified in adopting this attitude. They know our Foreign Oifice, they know its slackness and its shiftlessness in the face ofa little bluff. Moreover, their experiences'on the Niger had taught them what an expedition could accomplish by rushing the position. They have retired from Boussz, but their cleverness in occupying that town gave them a clear_ advantage when they came to deal with Lord Salisbury. Sein the case of Fashoda, it. may not be the intention of the French Government to endofée the action of Major Marchand in occupying the town on the White Nile—if he actually has arrived there—bat with this in hand they might be able to frighten "ur Foreign Office into paying a rice. All their recent experiences in dealing with our Foreign Office justify them in claiming as much as possible in every direction, because the more they claim the more they are likely to get. The capacity of Lord Salisbury to concede gracefully has not yet been plumbed.

Farther on in the same article the Saturday explains that. because Fa-shode was captured by the Dervishes from Egypt, it does not become neutral territory which any enterprising European nation may occupy.

Egypt has never ceased to maintain that the Equatorial Provinces were her territory, from which she was expelled by' superior force, just as France was expelled from Alsace-Lorraine; and now that she has defeated her old enemy, she resumes her rights over the lost. provinces, just as France will do in Alsace-'Lorraine when the time comes."

The French Government have known clearly for over three years at least that under no circumstances would Great Britain recognise any French rights in the Nile valley. Great nations do not threaten each other except in very unusual cireumstances, but the statement of Sir Edward Grey, the Under-Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs in Lord Rosebery's Government, was as decided as it could be without being an actual threat. He was asked in the House of Commons on the 28th of March, 1895, as to reports then current that French expeditions aiming at the valley of the Upper Nile had been authorised by the French Government. In reply he made a statement, deliberately prepared and carefully expressed, and obviously intended to be read on the other side of the Channel, as well as heard in the House of Commons. His words were:—'I am asked whether or not it is the case that a French Expedition is going from the - West of Africa with the intention of entering the Nile Valley and of occupying up to the Nile. We have no knowledge and no reason to suppose that any French Exition has instructions or intentions to enter the Nile Valley. And I would go further and say that after all I have explained about the claims which we consider we have under past agreenients, about_the claims which we consider that Egypt may have in the Nile Valley, dormant, but never. withdrawn, and adding to that that those claims, and our views.with regard to those claims, are fully and clearly known to the French Government, and have been expressed to them—I say I cannot! think it is possible that those rumours deserve credence. Because the advance of a French Expedition under secret instructions right from the other side of Africa into a territory over which our claims have been Known for so long would be not merely an inconsistent and unexpected act, but it must be perfectly" known to the French Government that it would be an unfriendly act, and would be so regarded by us."

OurFrench contemporary inShanghai translates "unfriendly" by "hostile," and a hostile act is very little short ofa casus belli. Mr. Chamberlain rose after Sir Edward Grey and said that so far as his opinion went the declaration of the Under-Secretary was perfectly satisfactory. The Morning Post of the 12th ult. shows very clearly how fully justified Reuter was "in saying that the French must give way The action of ghe French Government, if it has authorised the presence of French officers ut Fashoda, amounts to an open contempt of British declarations, British policy, and British power. For Sir Edward rey's statement is tantamount to an assurance that the dispatch of " French expedition to the Upper Nile would be a casus belli. The action of the French Government must, therefore, be interpreted to mean either that Sir Edward Grey's assurance was not believed in France or that the French Government desired a war with this country. The Government of Great Britain, is, therefore, now in the position that it must no meaning, or must gratify the desire of the French Government for war. We can hardly suppose that the French Government seriously intends to bring about a war with Great Britain. The French abject isto obtain a footing on the Upper Nile, which will be accomplished without difficulty if the question is once allowed to become the subject of negotiation. Tt is nataral enough, expecially after the recent success of similar action on the Niger, that the French Government should try what can be effected by bold action in' the way of expeditions for the purpose of occupying ground which it is intended to claim. In ease the claim is not recognised, and threatens to be the cause of serious trouble, the expeditions can always be withdrawn, but why withdraw them if a compromise can be effected that is the French view. The British view is that there shall be no French territory on the Nile Valley, and that the French expedition and all claims accom= panying it or founded on it must be un-{conditionally withdrawn. The British Government has, no doubt, already made private communications to the French Government which car leave no doubt in {the minds of those responsible for French policy as to the gravity of the situation.

Unless 'Lord Salisbury had made p his mind that nothing should induce England to go to war again, he was obliged to insist on the withdrawal of Major Marchand from' Fa-shode, after Sir Edmund Grey's declaration and Mr. Chamberlain's approval of it. Fortunately the British public and Mr. Chamberlain know enough about the Nile Valley to keep Lord Salisbury up to the mark. If.they had known as much about the China question, we: should not have had to suffer the humiliations

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account