24th Dec. ConsIDERING the incomparable services that Sir Robert Hart, Bart., has rendered to the world by his direction of the Imperial Maritime Customs during nearly forty years, services that the Queen recognised by appointing him her Minister at Peking, an appointment which Sir Robert accepted and then felt obliged to resign, we regret very much that he should have reappeared in the public Press after such a long interval and over his own name with such an extraordinary article as that which appears in the November issue of the "Fortnightly Review" with the heading "The Peking Legations: a National Uprising and International Episode." The article itself can only be considered an aberration, the fruit of the unusual and hard experiences of the siege on a man accustomed to such a perfectly regular existence as Sir Robert's was. Such a rude change in long-settled habits of life must disarrange any man's thoughts. Even to a_ brilliant youngster like the late Mr. Townsend, who welcomed the siege as offering a fund of novelty and adventure, it palled and became wearisome before the end, and we can easily understand the effect it must have had on the Inspector-General of Customs, who saw his house, his archives, his collections of a lifetime swept away ruthlessly in a night and himself a refugee with his staff in the Legation, his death sought with shot and shell and fire by those he had served so long and so faithfully. How gallantly he bore himself throughout we know, refusing to be treated any better than his own subordinates; no doubt the writing of this article was an amusement to him, and he put down what he thought at the time, but he should have given the matter longer consideration before publishing these thoughts. The despairing messages that reached the outer world from him from time to time during the siege show, now that we know the facts, that Sir Robert was not untouched by the sufferings he underwent, and we are convinced that if he had kept this article by him for thirty-eight days instead of eight days after General Gasclee and the Indian troops marched in, he would have altered it considerably. What makes the article as it stands more regrettable is, that it is accepted at home as the matured opinion of one who knows China better than any other foreigner, whereas it may well be doubted whether Sir Robert does know the China of to-day at all well. He has voluntarily immured himself in Peking for years, only taking brief excursions once or twice in the summer to Pei-taiyo, which is little more than a suburb of Peking, and his direct knowledge of the rest of China and the outer world has been gained from the reports of his subordinates all over the empire and the pilgrimages of globe-trotters to his shrine. No one could become by his own efforts such a great man as Sir Robert undoubtedly is without having a broad, a receptive, and a digestive mind; but the broadest mind is narrowed by living for years without achango in such an atmosphere as that of Peking. Sir Robert's contribution to the history of the crisis is, of course, deeply interesting, with all the peculiarities of its style—there are sentences of nearly fifty long lines without a full stop—it is full of life and vigour and stands high among the numerous histories of the siege that have already seen the light; but the deductions that follow Sir Robert's description of the operations cannot be accepted without demur.
Sir Robert begins by acknowledging that Peking was well warned of what was going to happen, but "Wolf!" had been cried so often that no one heeded the warnings; as we have mentioned before, we ourselves were blamed from Peking for publishing unnecessarily alarmist rumours, "At the same time some of us," says Sir Robert, "regarded the movement as very significant, but we did not expect it to become danger before autumn: its earlier development was a genuine surprise." We believe that the actual outbreak was somewhat premature, but there were plenty of siges, even at Peking itself, in spring that it was close at hand; and there would have been no surprise if the laymen in Peking had deigned to accept the warnings of the inissionaties, both Protestant and Catholic, who at least, it must be confessed, are the best authorities as to what ig going on in the interior of China. More than a year ago we definitely prophesied the conflagration of which the siege of the Legations was the prominent incident, and on the 14th of February last we wrote: "It is morally certain that the opening spring will witness a rising such as foreigners in China have never seen before. The whole country, from the Yellow River to the Great Wall and beyond, will be in a blaze of insurrection, which will not only annihilate every foreign interest of every sort in the interior, but will drive every foreigner out of Peking and Tientsin under conditions which it is not difficult to foresee." How nearly Tientsin fell, and how certainly Peking must have followed if Tientsin had gone, we know well now.
The question of warning is labelled (A) in Sir Robert's article: the second paragraph (B) is a very inportant one. It begins: " Criticism, to be of value, must be just, and must recognise whatever of fact or sentiment has been interwoven with what has oceurred—causing its birth, shaping its aims, interlacing its products, and justifying both inception and growth." We pass over the remarkable confusion of metaphors in this sentence, and read on to find in gravely stated that "the Boxer Association, patriotic in origin, justififable in its fundamental idea," was "in point of fact the outcome of either foreign advice or the study of foreign methods." The Chinese Government were exasperated by various commercial stipulations sanctioned by treaties, by. missionary propa-gaudism, by the interference of Roman Catholics in litigation, and the demand that Roman Catholic priests should be given official rank, by the Kiaochou affair, and other cessions of territory; and men such ay Hsii
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.