The Archive · 1898

HAROLD FREDERIC AND THE CHRISTIAN SCIRNTISTS

The Coroner's jury in the case of Harold Frederic have brought in a verdict of manslaughter against Miss Lyon, the woman with whom he lived, and Mrs. Mills, the "Christian Scientist" who "'communed with the Almighty" on his behalf at the rate of a guinea a week. The jury found that bodied from lack of medical attendance, and that Mies Lyon and Mrs. Mills, having been his quasi-guardians, are responsible for his death. Hvdrybody is pleased that a blow has been struck at the pernicious and fraudulent superstition which calls itself Christian Science," but it is very doubtful whether the verdict can be maintained in law, for it is only in the case of little children and helplessly incapable persons that the law holds their guardians responsible for obtaining medical treatment, and the ence seems hardly to bear out the contention that Harold Frederic was in this condition. The fact is that Frederic objected to the lotions which the doctors imposed on his mode of life, especially in the matter of smoking and drinking, and that he therefore readily yielded to Miss Lyon's persuasion that he should put himself under "Christian Science treatment." It is impossible, therefore, t absolve Frederic himself of large share of the responsibility for his death. However, the two women have been arrested on the coroner's warrant and admitted to bail; and in due time they will be tried. It.is probable that the jury were to some extent influenced by a perfectly natural and well-deserved sympathy for Mrs, Harold Frederic and her children in the verdict which they returned, atleest 80 far as it affected Miss Lyon.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account