The Archive · 1901

The Peace Conditions

28th Dec. 'THE conditions on which the Powers are willing to withdraw their troops from the metropolitan province of Chibli have now been made public, and the Chinese Peace Plenipotenflaries have been informed that they must take them or decline them as a be whole, and that they are not open to discussion. It is interesting to examine them a little carefully and see how far they fulfil our hopes on the one hand, and are likely to be acceptable to the Chinese on the other. As the resultant of the wishes of eleven different Powers, they are not likely to be completely satisfactory to any one of those Powers, and it is a matter for congratulation that so many Powers with such varying interests should be able to agree on any joint programme at all. It is quite possible that Li Hung-chang may persuade his imperial mistress to give a formal assent to these terms in the hope that the allied armies will then go away, and that it will be a long time, after this year's experience, before they will all unite again to coerce China even if she evades the execution of these conditions, as it will be in her nature to try to do. We are not ourselves satisfied by these conditions, for they include too much and leave out too much; but we must remember Hesiod's aphorism shat fools do not know how much more the half is than the whole.

Passing over the preliminary summary of the crimes committed by China, which are properly brought home to the Chinese Government, no heed being given to the convenient fiction that they were the acts of rebels whom the Government was unable to control, we come to the first condition, in which there is no difficulty. It includes the dispatch of an extraordinary embassy to Germany and the erection at Peking of a suitable monument to the late Baron von Ketteler. The second condition includes the inflict tion of the severest penalties on the instigators of the outrages, which the Kmperor has already been allowed to profess his willingness to carry out, and the punishment of all towns in which foreigners have been killed or ill-treated, by the suspension of official examinations for five years. This is a well-deserved penalty and an appropriate one; nor is it likely to be opposed by the Government any more than the third and fourth conditions which comprise compensation for the murder of Mr, Sugiyama and the erection of an expiatory monument in every foreign or international cemetery that been desecrated. To the Chinese mind as well as that of Westerners the desecration of a we is the act of savages desfitute of any knowledge of propriety. The fifth clause isa crushing blow at the independence of China. It is impossible for a country to be independent that is not allowed to buy or manufacture arms or munitions for fts own use. - It will be noticed that the Japanese Minister signs with the rest the note containing this condition, but it will remembered that the Japanese Consul-General here withdrew his name from a similar notification when it was promulgated hose. The principle of the payment of compensation, provided for in the sixth condition, has already been accepted by the Chinese, and they will no doubt be prepared to admit the necessity for a recourse to Western skill in raising the necessary funds, The seventh section authorises the maintenance of Legation guards at Peking, the construction of defences round the Legations, and the removal of Chinese houses from their vicinity. This condition we refer to again later on. It is followed by two conditions which seem likely to be the hardest of all for the Chinese Government to swallow, providing as they do for the destruction of the Taku forts and any other Chinese defences between Peking and the sea, and the establishment by the Powers of military posts between these two points. It seems to us that these three last conditions and the sixth are likely to defeat their own object. We want the capital re-established at Peking, though nothing is said about this in the conditions; but is it likely that the Court will come back to a capital in which the Foreign Ministers are to have a small fortress of their own with a permanent garrison, while the Court itself is allowed no means of defence, and is put at the mercy of the smallest Power that has a grie~ vance and a gunboat? If Peking is to be left with no arms, no forts, and access to the sea only at the pleasure of the allies, it will, we imagine, cease permanently to be the capital of China, and in that case the reason for these conditions disappears, The alternative is to put the government of China under the formal protection of all the allies, which will not be an easy matter to arrange and carry out. The tenth condition provides for the publication all over China of the punishments provided in these conditions and of a proclamation prohibiting membership of an antiforeign society under pain of death and of another edict recognising the responsibility of provincial officials for outrages occurring "in their districts under the penalty of permanent removal from office. The full execution of this condition will depend, of course, on the vigilance and pressure ex-excised hereafter by the Powers. The Chinese Government will doubtless agree to discussing changes in the existing commercial and shipping regulations, as provided for in the

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account