The Archive · 1901

Before H. Kia, Esq., Acting Police Magistrate

R. vy. Mantisez.

Manuel Martinez, bandsman on H.M.S, Orlando, was charged with having assaulted and attempted to stab one Emmanuel Vassallo with a sword in the house No. 1334, Tsungming Road, on the th inst.. and also with unlawfully cutting and wounding Gandencio Mercado with 4 sword at the same time and place.

Prisoner had previously been taken before the Spanish Consul who said that ho was rot a Spanish subject, and before the American Consul, who found that he was not an American' subject.

Inspector A. Aiers, sworn, said that at 6.30 p.m. on Friday last the prisoner was handed over to the police by Major Watson, the Provost-Marshal. The Provost= Marshal also handed to the police a letter, (Letter produced and handed in.)

Emmanuel lo, sworn, stated that he was one of the complainants, He w:

The salaries of the band were the band-president. On Thursday, inst., witness had been to sce the band-president, who was sick and in the hospital, to ask him about engaging Filipino bandsman. He afterwards went to sce this bandsman, whose name was Mereado, and arranged for him to commence his duties on board the Orlando. Ho took Mercado to tiffin at the Hotel des Colonies and about half past two or three lost in the struggle.

Witness, continuing, said that he had not seen the weapon in prisoner's posses sion before. On secing the struggle ho went inside again and shut the door. A few minutes later Mercado came in with the sword. Shortly afterwards prisoner came in and was then quite quiet. Witness asked him why he fought with a weapon like that instead of using his fists. Prisoner stayed in the room for about twenty minutes and then went out. Witness saw him again at the Shanghai Rail-ay Station about two hours later when {he was going by train to join his ship. He went aboard at about seven o'clock in the evening. Witness reported the mattes to the commander at 11.30 next morning, after muster rounds, and showed the sword. The commander enquired into the matter and told witness to inform the captain, The captain said that it was a matter for the police and prisoner was therefore arrested.

In reply to his Worship, witness said that the prisoner did not attempt to stab him but he supposed that he intended to do so.

Gardencio Mereado, the other complain-ut, was then sworn and gave corroborative evidence. He added that when ho arrived at his house he saw that prisoner had a stick in his hand. When Vassailo told prisoner not to get drunk the latter got very angry and wanted to fight Vas-allo. id "Don't fight in my house, Keep quiet." Prisoner raised his fist and wanted to. strike Vassallo, but ness and a Filipino friend stopped him. Prisoner then pulled out 2 sword from the stick. On seeing this witness seized the prisoner's hands and with the aid of his friend pushed prisoner outside the door. Vassallo stopped inside the room,—Witness followed prisoner out and seized the sword and came back into the house. Prisoner then went away and got a bamboo with which he commenced to heat the door. After a time he quietened down asd came into the house, He apologised for what ho had done and shortly afterwards went to the Railway Station to proceed to his ship. Witness said that both his hands had been cut in the struggle for the sword.

The witness's statements were interproto'clock told him to go home and get ready ¢1 to prisoner vy Mr. Souza and prisoner to go aboard. Witness accompanied Mer- admitted that they were substantially cade to his house, No. 1,854, Tsungming correct. He did not wish to put any ques-Road. On entering the house they sw" tions. that the prisoner was inside.

His Worship said that the first charge asked prisoner why he had not come tind not been proved to his satisfaction. aboard the ship that morning, and asked The evidence of the witness Vassallo did him what he meant by breaking his leave. not prove that any attempt had been Prisoner replied that that wae not wit- made to stab him. With regard to the ness's business. Tt was the business of the second charge, it seemed clear that. pri-officer. Witness replied that he would soner had drawn the sword but there did sce whose business it was when he got on not seem to have been any malicious inboard. Prisoner had had leave from 1 p-m. the previous day until 9 o'clock that morning. Witness then told him to come aboard in the evening and not to get there was a programme to be pla:

evening. Prisoner had been drunk ona previous occasion. Prisoner then asked Mereado to lend hima dollar, but witness said that he himself would give him a dollar. He gave prisoner a dolar and again told him not to got drunk. At this, the prisoner got angry and wished to fight "witness, but Mercado and tent. There had perhaps been an assault but no attempt to stab had been proved. The ease would be dismissed.

His Worship cautioned prisoner against carrying weapons and told him that ho might get into serious trouble if he made use of such a weapon agai Shanghai, 24th March. i R. x, Rem Anp omens, This was a case in which John Reid, Martin McCarthy, E. Holland, Arthur

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account