The Archive · 1897

His Lordship—Try

Witness (after a good deal of pressing)—*"T find this again, after I make together, and read it to you."

Mr. Wilkinson—Mrs, Carew was very good to you and to Miss Jacob also?—Yes, very kind to both of us, Now what do you think Miss Jacob wanted to do this for 2—I thought that she was very bad, but that she wanted to read the letters—that it was her principal desire to do so.

And you are quite sure it was as far back as August last?—Yes, that was the time.

And could you not tell us what was in the first of the letters 2—No, I could not.

Even if they were read to' you again How did she show her joy?—She hela the letter up in her hand and danced up and down.

And what did you say to her?—Nothing.

Mr. Lowder—How long did this piecing of letters go on—from the middle of August till when?—As far as collecting them was concerned, it started before August.

And down to what time did it extend I think till the end of September; but believe on some occasions it was after the family came back from Miyanoshita.

Mr. Patterson—I should like to ask one question. At the time the witness gave the deceased soda-water on the Sunday, was he able to get out of bed. Was he in bed; and did she see him drink the soda-water?

Witness—He was in bed.

Mr. Patterson—Did he sit up, or get up, to drink it: did he take it in bed?

His Lordship—Did she see him take it?

Witness—I did not see him take it.

Mr. Patterson—When she pourd the! soda-water into the tumbler, in which she saw some coloured fluid, did she detect any smell?—I had a cold at the time and did not smell anything.

Then with reference to the paper that she saw Miss Jacob's copying, how did she know that it was in Mrs. Carew's handwriting @—I_ know Mrs Carew's handwriting, having seen it about.

His Lordshlp—If you were shown two different handwritings, would you be able to tell which was Mrs. Carew's?—I think would.

Can you read English?—A little.

Show her this photograph: whose handwriting like Mrs. Carow's, but T cannot say.

is it in?—It seems to be something

Now show her this; whose hand is that in?—This looks like her writ His Lordship (to the Jury)—This last is Mrs. Carew's, the other is Miss Jacob's.

Reginald Colmore Porch was next called. He depas ed—I remember Sunday, the 18th of October last. I recollect that Mrs. Carew took the children to church in the afternoon of that day. The two spouses were living on the most affectionate terms, both during his illness and before his illness. Mrs. Carew once said, during his illness, that she thought about calling in Hunter, the nurse. This was about four days after he was taken ill—about Sunday or Monday. I remember, on the day of his death, before he was removed to the Hospital, that Mrs. Carew gave him an emetic.

This was about a quarter past two. Dr. Wheeler came about a quarter ofan hour afterwards.

Mr. Lowder—-You knew the deceased well Yes.

Did he allow his wife all the liberty she wanted in the selection of her male friends?—Yes.

Now with regard to himself, from your knowledge of his disposition, and from his conversation, did you gather that ho gave himself the same freedom?—Yes, I should think so.

Have you ever seen this piece of paper before (the flimsy bearing the words "MI. J.," Dearest Walter ")?—Yes.

Tell me, as nearly as you can recollect, where you first found it About the recond of Janusry'I found it in Miss Jacob's birthday-book (produced).

Had you even seen it before?—No, never before.

You went to see Mary Jacob, after she went to No. 2, Blufl, T believe Yes.

With what object did you go to see her? I went to see if she had taken any letters from the waste-paper basket. She sid she had gone to the waste-paper basket to see if she could find letters of her own; but I did not understand that she had taken any letters from the basket.

Was the deceased able to be up and about on Sunday, the 18th?—I should say he could; bné I did not see him up.

But afterwards on the Werlnesday, wasn't he up on a chair talking and chatfing?—I do not remember.

Witness detailed what occurred in connection with his visits to No. 2, Bluff to see Miss Jacob about the contents of the waste-paper basket. She did not give her reason for leaving the service of Mrs. Carew. She said she could not remain in the house any longer. The subject of evidence was not mentioned.

Did Mr. Carew ever suffer from malaria?—I think he did.

You remember saying at the inquest, "Dr. Wheeler made a mistake this morn: ing, when he said that Mr. Carew suffered from malarial fever"?—T did say so.

His Lordship read the note from the inquest book.

Mr. Wilkinson then said—Can you say why you said that?—I do not know. I think that he ought to have said that Mrs. Carew suffered from malaria, To his Lordship—I am not certain whether Mr. Carew suffered from malaria or not.

Mr. Wilkinson—You remember Wednesday, the 21st?—Yes.

You remember Miss Jacob mentioning what Maruya's man said about. buying "plenty deadly poison?"—Yes, but. she did not mention Maruya's name she said simply the chemist.

Lordship—What did she say Witness—He wanted to know ' why she was getting plenty deadly poison."

Mr. Wilkinson—Did you mention the matter to Mrs. Carew?—No.

Did it not strike you that the making of such a remark by a chemist.was something out of the common and was worthy of con ment?—No, not in the least. I knew arsenic was & medicine as well as a poison.

Did it not occur to you that it was a remark calling for some' action?—No, not in the way she told it me.

She said to you that the chemist had asked her "why you buy so plenty deadly poison?'"—Yes, but in a very casual way.

Was not the communication serious enough?—Not, in the way she said it.

But she did convey to you clearly that the chemist wanted to know why she got plenty deadly poison?—Yes.

believe that you said at the inquest that you did not know but that the purchase of arsenic was in accordance with Dr. Wheeler's orders?—I do not know now.

His Lordship—TI will read the note. "I did not know at that time that the arsenic was not purchased at Dr. Wheeler's orders."

Mr. Wilkinsoi—You knew nothing about: what the deceased was suffering from?—I knew he was vomiting.

You said at the inquest that you did not know what his complaint was?—I meant T did not know what he was actually suffering from.

"But you observed the vomiting symptoms?—Yes.

You say you had seen Mrs. Carew give her husband his medicine?—Yes.

And that he had several medicines, but you could not tell their names?—I did not know what they were.

Mrs. Carew mentioned to you that Dr. Baelz was wired for and he was coming She told me she had wired to Dr. Baelz once she said that he was coming, but that he could not come.

That he was coming, or had come?—He was coming, but that he did not come.

"You also said that you never saw his medicines administered to him except by your sister?—Yes.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account