Some people may be led away by the argument that we are now asked to pay for a privilege which we ought to have enjoyed under the Treaty of Tientsin. AS a matter of fact of course, the consumer pays the duty on imports, but putting this aside, the proposition before us now is that in return for a surtax of one and one-half times the import duty leviable in the terms of the Protocol of 1901, i.e. an effective 5 per cent converted into specific gluties on the basis of the average values for the years 1897, 1898 and 1899—which specific duties to-day represent a little over 4 per cent ad valorem—foreign goods will be absolutely free from all taxation, examination, and delay. The proposition goes even further, in the opinion of the Committee, than that put forward by the Association in 1896 in that, effectively to secure this freedom from taxation, examination or delay, the Chinese Government undertakes to remove all barriers of whatever kind collecting likin and such like dues—reserving to itself however, the right under certain conditions to' tax native goods for native consumption at the place of consumption. The Chinese Government has clearly and definitely undertaken that the arrangements to be made for the collection of this tax shall in no way interfere with foreign goods or with native goods for export abroad. No information as to the incidence of this tax is given—nothing about the methods and rales for its collection, and the absence of this information is, I think, to be deplored, but as T have just said, what we have to consider from the British merchants' point of view is whether the Treaty which our Government proposes to make with China, leaves it open, either in its spirit or its letter, to the Chinese to introduce a form of taxation or obstruction which will prejudice foreign trade? I think every fair-minded man will admit that it does not. There is no ambiguity in the language of the section dealing with the consumption tax, it being distinctly laid down that it shall not be levied on goods while in transit, and from all taxation, delay, or stoppage after that goods of foreign origin shall be free having passed the Custom Houses. T am not prepared to say that China will not endeavour to levy the consumption tax on foreign goods, but if she does it will be in direct violation not merely of the spirit but of the actual letter of the Treaty, and I think we may really rely on the British Government of the 20th Century to prevent flagrant abuses of the present Treaty. It will, of course, still largely depend on our persistent energy and vigilance and also on the activity of our Government to xee that China keeps her engagements, but this remark applies, as I have already observed, to any agreement we might make, however strongly worded. Looking at the Treaty as a whole your Committee. do not profess to say' that it is perfeet—by no meansebut what they do say is thit it is a distinct advance on the Treaty at present in existence, and an advance also on the proposition made by the Association in 1896, and that we can, consistently with our past policy as an Association, approve of the increase in the import duties in return for the advantages, privileges, and safeguards therein provided. Iwould even go further than this and say that after all that has been said by this Association and the numerous representations which have been mad> to our Government to remove inland taxation on foreign goods, it would be inconsistent to reject this proposal unless there is more to be said against it than that the Chinese will totally disregard its terms. The Committee do not say that the measures adopted to safeguard foreign trade are in their present form the strongest that could hare been devised—Sir James original proposals were thcoretically more comprehensive and less open to possibility of evasion, but I would remind you that these proposals were rejected by British manufacturers—shortsightedly I think—and it is doubtful whether they would ever have been accopted by the Chinese Government except under compulsion. The present Treaty at all events goes as far as anything the Association has ever proposed.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.