The Archive · 1902

The Consumption Tan

Next as regards the Constmption Tax on native goods which has been so much criticised. "It has been asked why is this, a purely native Tax, dealt with in the Treaty at all? The answer is plain; it is dealt with in the Treaty in order that it may be regulated and defined. It has also been asked how this tax is to be collected? The collection one would say would naturally be made on the arrival of the goods at point of destination; it has been suggested that it will be necessary to examine the boats to see what amount of their cargo is foreign and what amount native; nothing of the sort; no exactions can be made on goods as long as they are in transit, it is only at destination that any tax can be imposed; as to the amount of the tax to be levied, it was clearly impossible for the Commission to draw up a tariff for the whole of the internal trade of China the Treaty stipulates that the tax " shall be levied at a uniform rate on goods of the same description" and it is pretty certain that the Trading Guilds and Cor-Parations will, from what we know of them, be well able to take care of them—selves. In any case it seems to me somewhat altruistic should we as an Associa tion now show ourselves so careful of the interests of native trade, seeing that our efforts have all along been directed towards securing only the freedom of our own trade, to obtain which we have expressed ourselves as willing to pay an import duty practically the same ax the one now arranged, while leaving the whole machinery of likin standing, and without claim to interfere with China's tain; her domestic trade as she pleases. Thi real fear, I fanes, ax regards the Consumption Tax is that attempts will be made to levy it on foreign goods; after past experience I admit that it ix not unreasonable to fear that the attempt may be made, and if so the Treaty will be broken; but I submit to you that the ciremnstances, when the likin barriers are abolished, will be very those when the likin abdominal ated all the trade; the great bulk of our imports have travelled without taking protection from likin, and such as ha moved under the protection of the Transit Pass received, ax we know, scant courtesy at the hands of the provincial officials for the reason, as we believe, and have over and over again stated, that the 'Transit duty did not find its way into their exchequers; further, beyond the question of likin in transit, there was the destination tax to be faced, a tax which though we have inveighed' against it as being contrary to the provisions of the "whatsoever clause" of the Tientsin Treaty, has been admitted by our Government to be an allowable exaction, provided that it does not exceed the amount of the local taxation on similar goods of native origin; therefore under the old Treaties you have a hopelessly mixed conglomeration of treatment of goods, some paying likin and some supposed to be free from likin, but all paying an indefinite tax at destination—under so confused a system can it be wondered at that the nnultifarious tax collectors found opportunity for a rich harvest? Under the new system proposed by the Treaty the great point stipulated for ix "free transit" of goods—a point urged with the utmost insistence by foreign merchants in all representations that they have made as regards their for je—the Treaty goes a long step beyond those representa tions, and stipulates for "free transit for all goods, whether native or fo as well as for the exempt goods from taxation at des we not. then be, under th ment, in vastly hetter pos ition than ever {the foreign merchants China have worked for? The fear that the Conswmp-Tax (or in other words our old friend the Destination Tax) will continue as a levy on foreign goods, may be combated the oft-expressed opinion of the ion that conciliation of the prov cial authorities, by securing to them a proper share of the revenue collection, was what was required to relieve our trade of the muitifario nil_exactions which have been the burden of our complaint, and seeing that we have never in the past made representations of any kind suggesting interference with China's right to tax her own domestic trade, I must really leave it to the propounders of the brand-new and truly altruistic idea of native trade protection, to explain their attitude in the present, and their silence in the past. To conclude this portion of remarks, it is suggested that the Des tination, or Consamption Tax, w tinue to be levied on on return suggest that the position of the native trader (the distributor of our goods) will be vastly different under the new Treaty than under the old? Under the old Treaty he can hardly know, in the neral confusion of the system of tax collection, where he is—when to pay the exactions demanded of him, when to refuse such payment. The new Treaty at least makes his position clear; he cannot be called upon to pay anything upon his imports during transit, and on his exports he can only be called upon to pay duty once, and that only if his produce happens to pass one of the few Custom Houses which China is permitted to retain; moreover the decrees of his own Government expressly state that on his foreign imports he shall pay nothing at destination; his position is at least defined as it never was before, and I believe that he is to be trusted to use his business capabilities to maintain his now defined rights.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account