The Archive · 1902

MISLEADING CRITICISM

And here, gentlemen, I cannot, having mentioned the question of the Custom Houses that China is allowed to retain, refrain from alluding to the criticism' which an opponent of the Treaty has made on the subject of the permi sion given for such retention. This critic has published a list of the stations (aum-bering over 40) which may remain; his list is correct, as I am informed. But I say, and I say it deliberately, that the form in which his statement is made is misleading; it is published in a form which gives the ordinary reader chance of appraising its real value, but simply leaves the impression that over 40 Chinese Native Custom Houses _remain to prey upon the trade. It will probably be news to many of you to know that the list includes Custom Houses at the ports, Custom Houses on the sea board and Custom Houses on the land frontiers. Now there can be no question of China's right to establish what Custom Houses she pleases on her land and sea borders, and as the Treaty provides that Native Custom Houses at the ports are to be retained, the list has to be considered in view of these exceptions also; it comes down to this then, that whereas the statement is so worded as to give the impression that the number of Custom Houses to be retained is about double that contemplated by the Commissioners, the real fact is that the number is not micro than about 18 so far as the published list is concerned; that there may be a few more, Ido not deny, for the document from which the list is taken is, I believe, dated about the end of last century, shen there were no Customs Stations in the provinces of Kueichou, Yunnani, and _Kansu—possibly the number of internal Custom Houses, and it was these alone that the Treaty contemplated, may reach 25. It has been objected that the safeguards against imposition of the Consumption Tax on foreign goods are either insufficient or non-existent. Well, the framers of the Treaty have in this matter kept two matters steadily in view, both of which have been consistently urged by the Association; the first is the car-marking of the Surtax funds, which can be come down upon in case of provincial irregularities; and the second, the extension of control by the TLM.C. over matters (in the words of the Treaty) connected with "Native Customs' affairs, Consumption Tax, Salt and Native Opium Taxes." You have for years expressed the opinion, or at least endorsed the opinion expressed by your Committees, that the greatest safeqiard for our trade lay in the extension of the operations of the Imperial Maritime Customs, "the one honest source of revenue that China possesses."

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account