"The question of the audit" continues to exercise thu minds of shareholders. The discussion which took place last week at of the Surrey Commercial Dock, Company is certain to be repeated at genres of other similar meetings until the fraud of which the Millwall Company hag been the victim are forgotten. The into, explanation by the secretary of the former company will give to those not acquainted with the working of large concerns an idea of what are the laborious preliminaries to a satisfactory audit. To test: the accuracy of an item of £52,000 in respect of out. standing charges in the company's books some 50 clerks were employed for a month and their work was supplemented by that of examiners and officials. The Auditors did not verify every item, but they made surprise visits or searches as to particular entries taken at random. Like most meet ings at which this matter is discussed, that which was held Inst week showed that there are two widely divergent views of the duties of Auditors. A very larve num ber of Auditors say that "their bu ness is purely that of the accountant in the narrowest sense. They are concerned only with matters of bookkeeping, Whether the books submitted to them describe the real condition of the company ix not their ethaps nowhere is there a franker and more succinct statement of this theory of very limited liability than in the by-Inws of the Institute of Chartered Ao. countant, according to which the Auditors of the society are liable only for wilful default. The contention of prohi ably most auditors is that it ix. wholly unreasonable to expect them to do more than look carefully into the accounts put before them. They are paid, as arulo, a small sum; they must perform their work rapidly and without interrupting the business of their employers; and if they are not to trespass on the provinces of the directors or permanent officials, how can auditors form an o assets or stock, or judge whether vouchers are what they purport tobe? The bus ness of the auditor is to see that the books are properly kept, and no more. That is, however, not the view of the ordinary shareholder; it is not the view of the Legislature; and, on the whole, it is not the View of the lawyer.
According to the original scheme of the Companies Acts, the auditor is to examine the accounts of the company and ascertain "the correctness" of the balance-sheets. To carry out this daty, he ''may at the expense of the company employ accountants or other persons to assist him in investigating such accounts and he may in relation to such accounts examine the directors or other officers of the company." The auditors' report should state whether, in their opinion, the balance-sheet is a full and fair balance-sheet, properly drawn up and exhibiting a true and correct view of the state of affairs of the company. The Legislature thus contemplated, however different may be the modern practice, a report which would give not merely a true and correct view of the accounts, but of the actual state ut the company's affairs. It did not contemplate unit which might be a snare or a farce. The Courts have inid it down, notwithstanding much opposition, that an auditor lay-be an "officer" within the meaning of section 10 of the Companies Winding Up Act, 1890, and, as such, liable for misfeasance; and they have declined to assent to the narrow conception of the auditor's duties which we have often of Into heard. "Tt is plain to me," said Lord Justice Vaughan Williams in a well-known case, "that if the auditors had added the stock in trade at the beginning of any year the purchase of raw materials in that year, and had deducted therefrom the sales, they must have seen that the statement of the stock in trade at the end of the year was so remarkable as to call for explanation, and they called for none. I agree that it is no part of the duty of an auditor to take stock. I agree it is not; but when it is said that it is no part of his duty to test the accuracy of the manager's certificate by comparison of the figures in the books that require auditing, I cannot agree." It is true that this view waa not altogether adopted by the Court of Appeal, which thought that an auditor must necessarily rely on other persons, and, in particular, experts, for the details of stock in hand when there were no grounds forsuspectingerror. But the notion that auditors are to be mere machines is not yy the Courts. In defining the responsibility of an auditor, the pro-sent Master of the Rolls His first duty is to examine the books, not merely for the purpose of ascertaining what they show, but also for the purpose of satisfying himself that they do show the true financial position of the company." And this is an artificial, strained view of an auditor's position. It is what nine out of ten shareholders expect at his hands, It agrees with the practice of conscientious accountants. It is satisfactory to find that the new Companies Bill does not impair or attenuate that responsibility, It requires him to use reasonable diligence in seeing that the books are properly kept and record correctly the financial and trading transactions of the company. He cannot do more; he is worse than useless if he does less. The fact is that he is the mainstay of the majority of shareholders and creditors. They ought perhaps to trust more to their directors, They do not, and will not. To nine out of ten persons who give a thought to the affairs of any company in which they are interested the certificate of the auditors is the security that all goes well. This confidence in what has been called the annual whitewash" may be foolish. But it exists, and the Legislature should take note of the fact. Unfortunately the Courts, as is often their way, hare not loft the matter in a perfectly clear state. They have distinguished between auditors de jure and de facto, between those perma-nantly appointed and those called in on a particular occasion, and they have decided that the latter are exempt from the sum-maty proceedings as to misfeasance, applicable to the former. Such exceptions complicate matters as to which all business men desire uniformity and clear ideas, We are not sanguine that auditors will be as useful to shareholders as they might be while there is reluct tance to pay them 4 reasonable reward for services which, if thoroughly performed, must be onerous. If they are to be "'offic-rs" they must be paid as such. If they are to scrutinize certificates of mana.ers and to scan the statements of experts; if they are to "protect " shareholders against directors or managers who misapply funds; if they are to make en.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.