For Owens ov tHe U.S, Creisen Wit-amores v. THe OWNERS OF THe STEAM Tee Rocker.
Mr. J. C. Hanson appeared on behalf of the plaintiffs, and Mr. A. P. Stokes for the defendants.
The petition of the above-named plaintifis sheweth as follows:—
1.—The plaintiffs are the owners of the steamship Wilnington and the defen ants are the owners of the steam-tug Rocket,—The Wilmington is States cruiser of 1,397 tons, and at the of the matters hereinafter referred to was lying at her moorings in the Whangpoo River on the Shanghai side abreast of the Ewo Road jetty landing, being the berth assigned to her by the Assistant Harbour Master, and the Russian steamer Meena (Mubha) was at the same time lying at anchor about 90) yards further up the river on the Pootung side.
At about 7.30 am. on the morning of the Ninth of August One thousand nine hundred and two the Mnhha which had no steam up was taken in tow by the said tug-boat Rocket by means of tow line belonging to the Rocket for the purpose of proceeding to the International Duck some two miles below. The tide at that time was running ebb at_a speed of about 1 knots per hour. Before, however, the Mnhha could be turned and pointed down the river the tow rope broke and the Mnhha was swept by the tide against the Wilmington, causing the latter. ship considerable damage.
4.—Those on board the Rocket improperly attempted to tow the Mahha down stream during the ebb tide.
5.—Those on board the Rocket ix properly attempted to. tow the Meena with ut proper or sufficient tow ropes.
6.—Those on board the Rocket improperly infringed Article 29 of the Regulations for preventing collisions at sea.
7.—The said collision and the consequences thereof were occasioned solely by the matters aforesaid or otherwise by the negligence of those on board the Rocket and were not in any way caused or contributed to by those on board the Wilmington. The plaintiffs therefore pray: against the defendants for the damage that the plaintits have, judgment occasioned by the collision and for the joos's of this suit.
2.—That the amount of such damage may be referred to the Registrar for his report.
—That the plaints may have such further relief as the nature of the case may require.
The answer of the above-named defendants is as follows 1.—The defendants admit paragraphs 1, 2 and 3 of the said petition, but deny all other paragraphs of the said petition.
The defendants further say that the steam-tug Rocket was on the occasion referred to navigated with skill and care, and they also say that there was no negligence on the part of those on board the Rocket.
Mr Has—Thit constitutes th+ pleading, but t wr- is an admis ion in the form of alaiter which [sou d siky to put in Tre addis ion is tha thos: o1 bowd the Wilmington dil not in any way cause emirbuts to tre collins. We admit shat such was the cass, (Let-er han sed i wihachut of te rie). The chert shows thet thy Wilmington was lyi ig just below the Ningpo Wharf, oppo-g|rite thy Ew+ Jetty, at her moorings, [and that the Wahh"' was anchored "be 90 yards high up on te Poutung sid+ tthe river. The tile was running Ca, }steom. I submit thit tre Wilmtg on, th t the collision wa~ no way at anchor, wud it being xdred to by her, the presumption of fault lies on the Ro"ket, an! tue burden of proof is -n the defendants to show th t the collision wis not cause t by any negligence on their part, in other words that. 1t was unavoitale, His Loriship—It mizht have been an unav iduble accident, or evused by noglig nee Mr. Hanson quoted tts, p ge ug wart of the judgment cont.iuthe-ein.
Mr. Sokex—The difference is very great in these cass, Mr. Hanson has not jed_a case where th-re was a tug wud Tt is different where two. ships ae concernd, one of which ra s into the other at anchor. 'There is n" presume ion the Rocket, becwse we dit not e'me into contact with the Wilming' The Mahha cane into contact with the Wilum rom.
Mr. Hanson—She was the moving ship which brought the Mabha int. such a position thit there was this collision. It is for the prma facie evidence to ~how thst there was n" fault on ths part of the His Lordship said that even if the presumption was hut there was n-ligence on the part of the Rocket tie negiige..ce be_ rovel by t.e evidence, Mr. Hanson—The preliminary, the Gcfendants, she measures aken to avoid coll sion, were hose. When the Mahha was dangerously clove t+ th-Wilmington, and t ye ¢0 I'sion unavida'le, the rope between the Rocket and tye Mnhh+ was cut by those on hoard the Rocket to prevent ths Mnhha fom receiving injury from te Rock-t, othe: words there was an admission thit the Maha was brought dangerously el s+ to the Wilmington wh-m sh c+ li b came un avoid ble. der ts minimise the dunaze, top event th- Maha ceiving fu ther i-ju y from the Rocket, the taut rope was cut. I will rouble your Lordshijs wih one case on the point of the liabi ity of " ship thet cvs the slamage. (Rep rt, Pro sate Divi-ion, 1886 volume 11, page 1i4, qu t-d, also Report, Probsts Division, 1892, page 187). In each coe th: ship ras dowa th other at anchor was held to blame. The
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.