Aug.
Whew a man is able to make presents in millions sterling, men will be almost as ready to read his opinions as they are to accept his gifts. It may be taken for granted that what Mr, Andrew Carnegie has to say in the June number of the "Nineteenth Century" will not pass unnoticed wherever two or three may be gathered together in the name of England.
He has taken for his subject the pessimism which he now finds broodingalmosteverywhere in Great Britain,
optimism Was greatest, and he pro-even ra 2 those whose former ceeds to show that the outlook is by no means so black as it is made out tobe. At the outset of his examination into the present position and what may be done to improve it, he points out, what the short-sighted and geographically ill-taught Englishman has not yet realised, that he "must cease measuring his one country with the forty-five countries of the American Union, E pluribus unurn." Figures show why: Great Britain has 41 millions of people, the United States 77 millions; the area of Great Britain is 127,000 square miles, that of the States 3,500,000 square miles. We have 500 people to the square mile, the Americans 30 only. The only reasonable basis for comparison, says Mr. Carnegie, is that of man for man. He takes that basis, and proceeds to examine.
finds that our credit has gone down owing to the South African war. Consols were at 113, they are now at 95. But, he says, "the strongest proof of British credit is that it is not destroyed; no other nation could have so recklessly disregarded the plainest dictates of sound finance.
Primacy in credit may yet be regained. Even now it is only the United States whose credit is higher at the moment than our own."
Turning to mining, weaving, commerce, and manufactures, we still hold the lead on the basis taken. Our shipping has declined in comparison, but only in comparison. Percentages count for little sometimes. By building a score of ships some States might increase their fleet a hundred per cent, while a score added' to ours affects only a decimal or two, There is" no cause for lying awake o' nights mourning over the position of Britain in shipping." With ship-building the same is true. While we continue to build three and five times as much as America and Germany respectively there is no immediate cause for alarm. Atlantic travel has gone largely to German ships for natural reasons. They have the whole Continent to draw'from. They take the emigrants from Northern Europe, vit Bremen and Hamburg they draw those from Southern Europe and France through Cherbourg, and they do not neglect even those from England, calling at Southampton and Plymouth out and back for their especial benefit. This shows why it may pay the Germans such ships would not pay with British to put on extra fast vessels while
passengers only, and we have ceased to compete in speed accordingly.
With regard to iron and steel production, the output for Creat Britain, man for man, "will remain greater than that of any country except the United States." No other nation compares with her in steel, even in the aggregate, "but an unreasonable man can, of course, easily lament his country's decadence, because it produces five millions instead of 10}, which half a continent produces."
Concerning trade, Mr. Carnegie shows that, taking imports and exports together, our commerce is not declining. "It has apparentl reached its limit, and is not patio ing, having remained practically stationary for, say, ten years." Decrease of export, however, is not necessarily the evil that the pessimist thinks it must be. Is may mean that much that formerly went elsewhere is now being productively consumed at home, a by no means deplorable condition. We quote in fall what the writer has to say respecting the commerce which most nearly affects us: "The vast interests of Britain in China are much in evidence at present, but shrink on examination. The amount that China takes of British products is only £5,000,000 per annum. Little Holland takes one-half more, and so does little Belgium, and the Brazilian and the Venezuelan republics each take more. A very big war can easily be stirred up in China, costing thousands of lives, and a hundred millions or two, which cannot well be spared, all in the cause of protecting a paltry five millions' worth of trade, yielding, perhaps £600,000 or £700,000 per annum profit. Nor is Chinese trade likely to increase much, for the Chinese need little that is made by Western nations, Great increase of her consumption of British goods is not probable, in the opinion of the writer, who has some knowledge of that strange land."
Some of this reasoning sounds more than a little fallacious. But we will let that pass. Inthe matter of taxation, we are told that both Germany and the United States are better off than ourselves, the latter especially so. We run into debt in the most light-hearted fashion, and have to pay accordingly. American States and cities are constitutionally prohibited from overstepping certain percentages of their property assessment. Then our conservatism is against us. France outruns us in electric appliances and motor cars, but "the writer expects Britain soon to be in the front rank here." Our armies, military and industrial, are too amateurish the qualities of the race lie dormant; the blood has not deteriorated, but it needs an exceedingly strong stimulus to bring the latent power out. The only thing
alarming is the "financial and poli-which Mr. Carnegie thinks really tical situation the aggressive temper which alienates other Governments and peoples, and which has mistaken territorial acquisition for genuine empire-making." There are, he says, rocks ahead, but he hopes that the good sense of the nation will prevent lier being wrecked on them.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.