The Archive · 1903

Shanghai Public School

Li Kev, W. Githert Walshe, See... Educational Committee. to acknowledge the receipt of your letter of the 3rd instant. vomupon the memorandum J had n the subject of the new eurri-Tis tone shows me that it will sable to risk a further reproof slisity " by inflicting on 1 detailed reply.

Allow me, however, to express at once I feel that those exp sions of opinion and of fact, write a strong sence of duty, should with so severe a reception. Te was un-ne scute me that the ate not Ie we ed to me ta deni it. AM that should have asked in sttch 2 connection weonld live been that the same confidence should have been reposed in meos the Comunittes: thonselves desire.

Bur there is a point of greater import= an the question whether Tam. cent the courtesy whic for more an thirty years has invariably been extended to me by Committees here al] and elsewhere. - I pass by the remarks in your third and fourth paragraphs as there am be no. great difference of opinion thereon. Similarly the point you in the fifth paragraph, respectii abundant room for' improvement nse, needs no comment. Tt is with the nest four that I wish particularly to deal In my first letter I stated that "on p.xi of the school prospectus, passed in conjunction with the rules at the rateers' meeting aforesaid, we find the fol-It has been definitely decided religions instruction shall n in the school.

comment on this reads thus:—quot tion from 'General Re-by the way have nothing to do with the rules passed a ers' meeting, as you assert)

2 stops short," etc., ete. "Th was arrived at (at) an ordin former committee, and had to do with the ratepayers' meeting referred to, which took place six months preview The school was taken charge by a committee appointed by the Coun-committee, sis it happened, composed almost entirely of personal friends Of riy own, none of wont had any desire in the dark as to their inten-have never had access to the mittee minutes, and when this parnti-religious ruling was first down' T cannot say, but I re-without fear of contradiction that the statement T made in my first lotter is stlstance, and that from the be-wax understood by everybody school should be secular. If the doubt my word upon this of the original hai, Mr. J. L. Scott, Tuln Morris, who, 1 believe, will testimony to mine. from minutes but from men, from were actors in the events to which T refe This. wwe hi anther objec tion disposed of, viz., that "the members of the staff were engaged on the sole understand tee to teach."

Inter whatever branches" in this extract it is evident from what T have said that there are understood words "tat a n, L repeat from anal knowledge. they always have beet understood.

10 the " Scripture " teaching.

only to point out a discrepancy tween paragraphs 4 and 7 of your letter. The first distinctly declares that no form is intended; the a Cambridge Bible "in the teacher only." Now, parts of the Cambridge edition which J have seen (Luke and Acts)

doctrinal from cover to caver. This isa point, however, upon which T do not wish to dwell.

T hope that in the preceding paragraphs T have said enough to convince you that 1 wrote was written not' only in 1 faith, but with an intimate know-of the circumstances. in which T n interested perhaps, feel slatements, as yor of plain fact is going beyond the hound: of friendly controversy. Very evident misconstrictions of plain facts," if it means anything at all, is a sounding raphra short Saxon word not genly heard in polite society. Tt is a phrase which reflects on my character as a teacher, and my honour as aman, and must either be fully substantiated or fully withdrawn. If you can succeed in proving its correctness in "the proper court when called upon," then my connection with the Public School ceases, since it will be obviously impossible for me to scholars labelled with the character of one who is given to "very evident misconstructions of plain facts."

Tam sending the whole correspondence on this subject to the Press in order that "the proper court," the ratepayers, may decide as to my fitness or unfitness to retain my post. "I much regret the enforced irregularity of this procedure, but there seems no other course oper.

Iam, Sir, Your obedient servant, Principal.

To the Editor of the "Norra-Cuina Day News." is uncertain how far the revelution the management of the Shanghai Publ col intended by the Educational ittce or intended by its Secretary is fally understood. The Rey. Mx. Darwent referred to one ph the introduction of religious instruction. There are two or three other phases whick ought tobe ted by the parents of the scholars attending the School, and also by the whole Tnady: of Ratepayers.

The. brief letter of Mr. Walshe first hed indicates only in part the action the Committee, but it reveals enough to the Committee is acting with a trary tv the large-minded and sinopotitan chiar of these Inter ional, Settlements. The longer letter Mr. Walshe to Me, ing shows bias sand spite even Tu the first place there is a bias in the watter of the curriculum, 'The curriculum the has been shaped in cordance with the needs in Shanghai pupils have been so trained that, after leaving the school, they could find' some empl ment sufficient ab least for a liveli-wand Ve of the hoy intended to enter any of the English Cniversities, or to use their education acquired in Shanghai positions in the home lands. Those who igh ambitions have gene-ally taken a course of study in some of the schools sp-cially suited for preparing them for what they desired. The existing curriculum of the Shanghai Publi¢ School might be called the "Shanghai" currie colum, while the one that is now decided the new Committee is a Cambridge curriculum, suited for the Cam: bridge local examination, or ultimately for cambridge or Oxford Universities, now cui is not even an English one Used generally in the public schools of England; still less is it a Scotch one, where the Public School system and practical technical instruction is superior to that of England. The old curriculum has: been worked out through years of local experience, while the new one has been voted in by a small Committee without the pupils, and only to a slight degree the aking into. their confidence the parents ut Principal and other teachers of the School, not consulting them till the syllabus was ready drawn up. This action is not merely revolutionary but arbitrary. There is too much of the dictum. ks of the school. It is only a litle over a year since a luge number of new text-books were ordered, sine English and some Aimeriean, after careful consideration the former Schou! Committee and the staff of teachers, New that these text. Tonks have just been purchased by the parents or guardians of the children, an-

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account