This was an application made by Mr. Browett, on behalf of the defendant in re Yung O. Kane v. A. J. Hudson, a case heard in Ningpo before the British Consul and decided in favour of the plaintiff.
Mr. Teesdale appeatet for the plaintiff.
His Lordship said he had intended to hear the motion ex parte and would hear first what Mr. Browett had to say on behalf of defendant to show cause why he should be granted leave to appeal, and if Mr. Browett made out a prima facie case, he would write to Ningpo for the judge's record. It would have to be a very strong reason indeed to cause him to make an order, and if Mr. Browett made out a ease he would adjourn and when the judge's record atvived Ar. Teesdale could address the Court for the plaintiff.
Mr. Browett sail on behalf of defendant he now moved that he might be granted leave to appeal to the Court ayainst the decision niven in the case in the Provincial Court at Ningpo, on the 26th of August last. Ho made the application under the last clause ut Section 119 of the China and Japan Order in Council, 1465.
Lordship that by that clause applicant would have to show that there had been a substantial miscarriage of justice, and if he could not he could not succeed.
Mr. Browett said he would read the affix davit, but his Lordship said it was unnecessary as he had read it.
Mr. Browett submitted that there had been no cause for action between plaintiff and defendant. In the first place plaintiff did not appear. There was no evidence produced at the hearing that the sum claimed (850) had ever been advanced by the plaintiff or that anything had done to place her in the position of plaintiff, as for instance by way. of assignment of the debt. Another point was that i€ defendant owed the money or any such sum, to a person entitled to sue Mr. Hudson would be liable to answer that action and the judgment in their suit would be no protection to his client. There was no evidence produced at the hearing that plaintiff had advanced the money; on the contrary, plaintiff produced a witness who testified that he (the witness) had advanced the money. In fact there was no evidence brought forward at the hearing connecting plaintiff with this transac tion in any shape or form. The evidence brought forward for the defence waa that defendant never received the money, and defendant's compradore testified that he had received $50 for the purpose of assisting a brother of the first witness for the plaintiff. Further, that he had received that money on his own account and defendant had nothing tod" with it. The evidence showed -that it was purely a Chinese case and should have been brought in a Chinese Court ayainst the compradore. Was it likely if defendant had received the money he would have gone into legal proceedings which cost him more than $307 Would he have risked injuring his reputation by so doing? Counsel was aware that the sum was small, but it was not the amount but the question of principle, and it would be a very serious thing indeed for defendant if the judgment was allowed to stand. It meant that h" would lose the greater part of his business, and would be Tooked upon by foreigners and Chinese as a rman not to be trusted. Counsel submitted that his client had acted rightly in refusing to pay the money, and it would be absurd to.think for enemament that aman would refuse to pay a paltry sum of $50 if he had actually received the money, When judgment was given by the Court at Ningpo, Counsel immediately applied for leave to appeal, and offered to deposit 2250 to cover' costs, but the Consul emphatically refused leave, and he consequently had to make application to that Court.
His Lordship said'the 119th clause gave this Court an extraordinary jurisdiction, which in cases like the present should only be exercised to prevent a serious miscarriage of justice through @ mistake or otherwise. He had read the papers in this case carefully and als" listened attentively to Mr. Browett, and it seemed to him that it was not a case in which ho could allow an appeal. fo take the points Mr. Browett had raised, first us to the question of plaintiff. The phintif in the petition was & woman, sid to be absent, but the man who actually paid the money was her chief witness, What would happen in a case like this? Why the people would go to the Consul to get justice, and the Treaty of Tientsin was quite clear as to what Consul's duties were. Ho would probably ask the Englishman to pay the money and if he declined there would be nothing for the Consul to do, in his intention to get justice for the Chinese, than to tell" the Chinese to institute a suit against the defendant. The poor woman had probably no lawyer and the Consul would be bound to lexd hee and examine witnesses on her behalf us far as possible.
mixed cases where Chinese were plaintiffs the Consul's Court was primarily one of reconciliation. In this case Consul might have amended the petition jing Ching Yung-lay as plaintiff or he might have proved that Chang was the plaintiff's agent. His omission to do this in ho way hurt the defendant, Next in ro-gard to Mr. Browett's point that the com-adore should have been sued and not adson, the compradore when acting within thescopeofhisemployment, was Mr. Hudson's agent, Hudson had b trumental in getting the man impi ind to Hud-fon these people came to get him out, Would they have gone to the compradore had he bean an ordinary Chinese and not Hudson's compradore? One of the affidavits stated that Hudson was pro-sent when the compradore received the money. In fact if the compradore received the money it was as Hudson's agent. They must look to what was done not what was said. Hudson was therefore rightly sued. In regard to Mr. Browett's argument in respect of Hudson's character and reputation a perusal of these papers led to the conclusion that the defendant hid been meddling with the administration of Chinese justice in a matter in which he asa British merchant was in no way con-corned. Ifhe had burnt his fingers th Court was not the place to come for a remedy. Lastly in regard to the sum of $10.50 said to have been repaid by the complainant to the plaintiff, if this fa was proved to the satisfaction of Judge at Ningpo he would be able in his Consular capacity to set off this sum against the $60 now in his hands. The motion was dismissed with costs.
The affidavit on file in the Court, which his Lordship took as read, was as follows I, Harold Browett, of Shanghai in the ina, Solicitor, make oath and —The suit was, on the 26th day of August 1899, heard and determined in Her Britannic Majesty's Provincial Court at Ning-
2.—Mr. E. F. Bennett, Her Britannic Majesty's Acting Consul presided as Judge, the Plaintiff was not _prosent and I appeared Counsel for the defendant.
3.—The plaintiff claimed $50 money had and received by defendant for and'.on her to know why the plaintiff was not. prerent.
4.—On -the opening. of the case-I requested
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.