The Archive · 1899

MUNICIPAL MATTERS

6th Oct.

WE are informed that the Members of the Municipal Council responsible for the refusal to allow a Japanese funeral service in the Crematorium building take much exception to the brief remarks we made on this subject yesterday morning. What they did, we are now told, was to inform Mr. Nishimaki that the service could not be held until the Ratepayers had been consulted, a communication which obviously ought not to have been reserved till the last moment, as these are ceremonies which cannot be delayed for a month or two in the summer in Shanghai. The Council did. not say that no other than a Protestant service could be allowed at the chapel, but they stipulated for a Christian service; it will be noted, however, that in Mr. Bland's letter of reply to Mr. Nishimaki, the correctness of the latter's account of his interview with Mr. Hewett is not impugned in any point. Mr. Hewett and his colleagues now object to being accused of bigotry and narrow-mindedness; but these charges follow inevitably from the correspondence as published yesterday morning. Mr. Hewett, it will be seen, told Mr. Nishimaki. that "the Council could not decide the question without the authority of the ratepayers but "by refusing to allow the Japanese service to be held they did decide the' question; "and their mistake is the greater from the fact that it turns out now that the so-called chapel has never been "dedicated as a Protestant Church, by a clergyman of the English Established Church." It would have been most improper if it had been so dedicated, unless its cost had been exclusively defrayed by members of or sympathisers with the English Established Church. As a matter of fact its cost was defrayed by all peoples, nations, 8°! languages, and religions. What Mr. Hewett and his colleagues should have done, if they ly thought they were not justified in declining to make any restrictions, was to say to Mr. Nishimaki that as the matter had gone so far, and he had been told by their own official that he could have his funeral service in the chapel, they would certainly allow it to take place, but would consult the ratepayers as to future applications of the kind. We are quite willing to believe that it was timidity, not bigotry or narrow-mindedness, that actuated Mr. Hewett and his colleagues; but they were not actuated by broadmindedness as they should have been, and it must have been hereditary intolerance that made them adopt the course they did, for we cannot really suppose that they thought the building would be desecrated by the performance in a part it of a Japanese funeral service, while they allowed a Japanese to be cremated in another part of it. We do not propose to go into the larger question, but it needs no argument to convince any levelheaded person that the use of a building put up at the public expense to partly shelter from the weather those who are engaged in paying the last offices to one whom they have loved or respected, cannot be denied to the public so long as the services are conducted decently and reverently. The incident is particularly unfortunate when, as we learn, Japan has just decided to recognise the Christian religion as one of the religious organisations of the country, putting the heads of the Christian communities all over Japan on an equality with the heads of the native religions in the Empire; and giving them all the right of direct representation to the Hone Minister in Tokio. It is only} by the widest tolerance in every direction that such a composite com-"munity as this is can be kept together. We shall be very much surprised if the ratepayers when called upon for their opinion do not endorse by a very large majority, if not unanimously, the temperate and dignified remonstrance of Mr. Nishimaki:—

Now, Sir, in common with many of our fellow residents here I think there is no place in the world so cosmopolitan as Shanghai is at present, and the fact of its being so is the pride and one of the sources of the prosperity of these Settlements. Such being the case. I could not think that the Crematorium built and maintained by the ratepayers of these most. cosmopolitan: set ents should be made for the exclusive use of only a certain section of this community.

"T consider that the Chapel in question is but a part of the Crematorium and not a distinct thing altogether, and that the very fact of its being built and maintained. by the Municipalty out of the general rates (2)

akes it quite clew that it is for the use of the whole community without distinction of nationality or religion, and should not be reserved for a particular section of the The decision of the Council to ut $500 out of the public funds, on the understanding that responsible trustees are appointed to administer the fund, to the family of Mr. J. Smith, who was killed at the recent fire in the French Settlement will be universally approved. We must suspend our judgment as to the Council's share in the dispute with the China and Japan Telephone Ca, until the appearance of the promised pamphlet; but we shall all of us, grumble as much as we have done at the present service, undoubtedly realise its value when it is taken away from us. As regards Tramways, we note that both our and the French Councils are agred as to the superior acceptability of the offer of the Shanghai Tramway Syndicate, Ld., and the public will learn with satisfaction that it is a very strong international syndicate, and that the terms offered are very' favourable to the Municipality.

The Report of the Land Assessment Committee appended to the minutes is a very interesting one. The Report begins by rather bearing out our contention before the Committee was appointed, that a reassessment this year was premature. There will, we fancy, be general approval of the common-sense principles which have guided the Committee in making the new assessment. The Report contains several hints which will doubtless not be lost on the Surveyor's department, which strikes us sometimes as being overloaded with side issues to the detriment of its attention to its main functions. There are two matters mentioned more or less incidentally in the Report which should not be overlooked. One is the naming of the roads, which is really in a chaotic condition, because instead of allowing it to grow up gradually and naturally as it was doing, Mr. Medhurst ut, it into a straight-jacket which as never fitted it; and the other is the absorption of native passages, alleyways, and roads by adjoining foreign landowners, which has been carried out to a really scandalous extent in recent years in the western suburb. We wish the Council could be induced to seriously consider the suggestion we threw out, not long ago as to the utilization and improvement of existing native roads in the Extension of the Settlement.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account