The Archive · 1899

Tramways in Shanghai

Lith Oct

On. Tuesday next the Ratepayers will meet to Consider a resolution submitted by the Municipal Council recommending the acceptance of a specific.tender-for a tramway concession-in'Shanghai. 'With the adoption' of the Council's reposition we believe a step will-be taken which will have discretion to formulate a scheme for; tatification by the Ratepayers by which the system be carried into effect."

'The Chairman of the Council at that time (Mr. Burkill) in submitting ithe resolution remarked: "We decided that it would-be a waste of time to take into consideration any proposals until we had first ascertained the Ratepayers' opinion as to ithe desirability of introducing tramways into Shanghai. If you decide a -great and increasing effect uj n \that the time has now come to take the prosperity of Shanghai. That this step, the resolution before you tramways have become a necessity will give the incoming Council auhere,-and will-be as-beneficial as they thority first to consider whether the have been elsewhere, the majority of 'Council will construct and work its residents fully realise, and the pass-own tramways, or whether it will re-, ing of -the resolution at the Rate-commend the granting of a franchise payers' Meeting in March of last year for a number of years to a construc-formally put -that conviction on retion Company or Syndicate, and fur-cord, and indicated that the comther, if a franchise be decided on, an mercial. capital of this country authority to choose the scheme which does not wish.to lag-behind some of offers the best inducements and the the smallest towns of Europe and best safeguards." In face of the America in-the conveniences of rapid adoption of the resolution by a sub-and economical transit. It is unstantial majority after this, what necessary therefore to dwell at length, words can be applied to the remarks upon the advantages which Shanghai i}, made in certain quarters that the may justly rely upon deriving from principle of the introduction of tram-the innovation. But in some quarters ways is still open and has never had the disconcerted upholders of the old ithe assent of the Ratepayers? It order: of -things are endeavouring,; would indeed be a sorry "waste of without the least show of reason, to.time," as Mr. Burkill showed, after postpone the reform: by contending arduous work on the part of the that the Ratepayers have not yet Councils on both sides of the Yang-approved the principle of tramways, and that the matter is quite open.

Kingpang, extending over practically eighteen months, and involving all Opponents of reform are often driven the expense so large a scheme entails to-strange tactics to delay progress,—if on Tuesday next a conservative butiin the -present case they appear minority were permitted to re-open not only unreasonable but audacious. the whole case and practically make Some three years ago the increased us a-laughing stock before the people traffic in our streets, the larger population overflowing into what we; were invited to consider our require-in various pee of the world who may call the suburbs, and the distances-between -the localities It must be obvious, therefore, that business and residence, indicated,8o far as the tramways are concerned Shanghai-as a suitable and profitable; we have reached the satisfactory field for the tramway. Schemes were point when the only question is prepared and the' matter discussed,; which tender the Ratepayers are to and although the former were re-accept. The information which has jected' it. was'obvious that the Rate-"been published as the outcome of the payers were not so much opposed joint meeting of the Councils renders to-the principle of tramways, as the task a comparatively easy one. that they hesitated without due (From the first the.tender of the consideration to commit themselves; Shanghai Tramway Syndicate stands to any particular plan. Meanwhile lout as the most businesslike. As public "opinion. grew in strength, both Mr. Mayne and Mr. Camus, the and -though very estimable gentle-Engineers.and Surveyors to. the two men were tobe found who be-'Councils point out,.the tenderers came amusingly vehement when accept unreservedly the conditions the possibility.was mooted of an; proposed. The tennis for fifty years, clectiic tran gliding past their houses, iand, irrespective of the Company's they.found few supporters. By the, earnings, the Municipalities are to sheer'force of daily observation and receive a fixed royalty commencing at eneral comment.the Municipal Fifty thousand dollars per annum, ouneil was-forced to again take up with an. increase of one thousand the.question, and at, the: Ratepayers' dollars for each succeeding year until Meeting -in "March, 1898, the follow-total of Ninety-nine thousand ing. resolution was carrie dollars per annum is reached for the "That. -the Council be, and is; fiftieth year of the concession. The hereby, authorised to consider the conditions for re-purchase, in the expediency -of the establishment event of the Municipalities wishing of-a—system of tramways -in the to take over the. tramsvays, are also streets of the Settlement, and in its! equitable. After fifteen years the Council can exercise that option at a price based on the net receipts for the previous seven years capitalised at six per cent. Put as concisely as possible this is the offer, and when we add that it is supported by names of the highest standing, we think it may be taken as a striking proof of independent confidence in the future of Shanghai The more carefully the offer is examined the more satisfactory does it appear, and though the concession of which we have to dispose is undoubtedly a valuable one, we believe that by throwing it open to offers from the whole world and allowing sufficient time to elapse, the Municipal Council is now in a position to sanction a scheme which will not only be an important factor in the dawn of a new era for Shanghai, but reflect credit upon it as a community of enlightened and sagacious business men.

12th Oct.

Is a letter which will be found in our correspondence column this morning Mr. Heffer dissents from our conclusion yesterday morning, that at the annual meeting of ratepayers in 1898 the principle of the adoption of tramways in Shanghai iwas carried by a much more than sufficient majority. Mr. Heffer bases his dissent on the terms of the resolution, which we may allow was not drawn with the definiteness that might have been more wisely adopted. We repudiate, however, in toto Mr. Heffer's charge that our article yesterday morning was not an impartial consideration of the matter treated; and we are sure that if Mr. Heffer had rubbed up his {memory of the meeting in March, 11898, or had read over again the published minutes of it, he would agree that no one who paid any intelligent attention to the proceedings came away from the meeting without knowing that, whatever the terms of the resolution as passed, the ratepayers had by a majority of 170 to.136 on a poll adopted the principle of tramways. This was certainly the view held by the Council itself, or it would never have been justified in putting various Companies to the expense of preparing and submitting tenders; and there was nothing in the Chairman's speech at the annual meeting of ratepayers this year to indicate any doubt that the principle of tramways had been adopted. We regret very much to see the existence of the disposition indicated in Mr. Heffer's letter "to alter a decree established."

We have already pointed out that Mr. Burkill described the resolution which Mr. Heffer considers so "open," tas designed "to ascertain the Ratepayers' opinion as to the desirability of introducing tramways into the Settlement." This was carried, and

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account