The Archive · 1899

A PHONOGRAPHIC WITNESS

Further light on the singular personality of Capt. Lebrun-Renault was obtained in cross-examination, He was asked whether he did not think it singular that Dreyfus should say, almost in the same breath, that he was innocent and that he had revealed secrets? The witness bluntly replied that he had no opinion to offer and that he simply reposted what she had heard. 'Iam a mere phonograph," he added. "Did you think atthe time that Dreyfus' words constituted confession of guilt?" the witness was next asked. Thad no opinion; that did not concern me," he replied.' Why did you not mention it in your report?"—Tt Yeas no business of mine," and so on. Confronted with Major Forzinette, Capt Lebrun-Renault admitted that he said Dreyfus made no confession. If the rest of his story was true, this remark was, of course, a lie, but he explained it by saying General Risbourg ordered him to say -he knew nothing about it. A truly reliable witness! Still, he did what he could for his side, and no doubt he was rewarded by the hand-shakes General Mercier and General de Boisdeffre gave him after he had finished his evidence, with Dreyfus' manly protest still ringing in his ears: Tam ast-unded that an admission I never made has been dragged into the declarations of innocence I have made from the very commencement. such 3 proceeding."

Every honest man must be indignant 7

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account