Mr. F. Axpensos—I have now to propose Resolution IV, dealing with the ucstion of the Telephone Service and posed franchise. It reads as follows Resolution IV.—That inasmuch as the negotiations with the China and Japan Telephone Company, entered into in accordance with Resolution VIII, passed at the Annual Meeting of Ratepayers en the 10th of March, 1898, now appear likely to result in that C pany's refusal to accede to conditions which the Council regards as essential, the Council is ling receipt of satisfactory alternative Tender for the establishment of a Te'ephone Service, to establish in its discretion and maintain such 4 Service out of the public funds and to raise for the purpose a loan, under the usual conus, for a sum not exceeding Tle. 130,00".
In placing this resolution before you, Gentlemen, the Council desires to lay stress on the opinion which its members. unanimously hold that it is undesirable for the community to undertake its own telephone service, except asa last resource and failing any satisfactory offers to undertake the maine by a company or syndicate of good standing. The authority which it is proposed you should confer by the present resolution is a general one which the Council considers will strengthen the hands of your representatives in continuing the negotiations undertaken in pursuance of the resolution passed at the Annual Meeting of last year. You may remember that the resolution to which I refer gave the Council power to negotiate with the China Japan Telephone Ca., or any other Company, and in its discretion to grant a franchise. The call for tenders which last year's Council issued under this authority produced only two offers: one being the tender of the China & Japan Telephone Ca., which has been published for your information, the other from a Dutch Company, whose conditions were not sufficiontly definite or favourable to call for serious attention. You are aware, Gentlemen, that the negotiations which the Council has entered into with the present Company have produced a situation which practically amounts to a deadlock, the company being apparently—indisposed to accept certain conditions which the Council regards as essential. In the correspondence which has been published for your information, it will have been observed that the two main points at issue are those of efficiency of service and terms of repurchase. There are other considerations which might possibly be dificult of settlement, but as the matter now stands, the Council has requested the Company to* express a definite acceptance or refusal on these two main ints before going further in the matter, in regard to the guarantees which the Council considers necessary on the point of efficiency of service, the proposals which we have made to the Company amount briefly to an agreement being made that in the event of one-third of the telephone subscribers complaining of the inelticiency of the system, or in the event of there being any question as to the apparatus used, recourse should be had to a Board of Arbitration, representing the Munici pality and the Company. To this con dition the Company's representative took exception, declining to submit to any tribunal regarding efficiency of service. When we consider that the sole reason for inaugurating a new system was that the tel-phone service had become exceedingly inefficient, it appeared to the Council that it would have been unbusinesslike to bind the community for thirty years to accept a service from the same Company without any recourse in the event of there being general complaints of inefficiency. regard to the matter of the Council's right totherepurchaseof the concession, the terms proposed by the Company were held by the Council to be untenable, and counterproposals, based on the ' arrangements ofered by the tramway tenderers, were put forward. I both these matters' reference has been made by the Company to its Direetors in London, and a definite reply may shortly be expected, but, in the event of non-acceptance of the Council's terms, the community must face the prospect of the possible closing of the exchange at the end of the year.
Another point which the Council allowed to remain in abeyance was the question of compulsory service, to which the Company's representative absolutely declined to agree, although the Council were propined to arrange conditions which would have safeguarded the Company.
It remains therefore for the Ratepayers of Shanghai to decide on the course now to be adopted in: this matter. In the Council's opinion it would be unwise to grant a franchise on terms which are asked by the China and Japan Telephone Ca.; on the other hand it may- possibly be that, no other tenderers will come forward with an offer more advantageous to the community. Should the negotiations, still pending, with the China and Japan Telephone Company remain in their present condition, and should you decide that. it is not expedient to comply with their views, it is lent that the community may be deprived of its telephone-service for some months, until arrangements can be made
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.