The Archive · 1900

Miscellaneous Articles

A NURSERY OF SEDITION

6th Apr Tum Foreign Settlement of Shanghai has had a good many supererogatory titles ju its brief existence of some fifty-six and a-half years. Early in its history some appreciative person called it the Model Settlement, and this: is a title that it has been anxious to live up to and has been proud of, as it has always been proud of the fact that until the present war in South Africa, its volunteer corps was the only British corps that had actually been under fire. Some thirty years ago the Duke of Somerset, then First Lord of the Admiralty, on the report of some evil-minded nai officer, characterised it in the House of Lords as a sink of iniquity, and the name stuck to us for a little while. Che late Mr. Henry Meller christened a race pony Sink of Iniquity, and the Duke of Edinburgh, who was on a visit here at the time, caused great amusement by drawing the Sink in a sweep. The Jupun Mail has now found a new title for us; we are nursery of sedition. It does not confine this opprobrious title to Shanghai; all the Foreign Settlements in China come under the ban, though most of them have done nothing to deserve such an insult even from the most rabid worshipper of the Empress Dowage!

In an article in its issue of the 28th of March the Mil says The Foreign Settlements in China are now presenting " curious object to the Peking Government. They may be said to be the nurseries of sedition. There is obviously some rebellions organisation in China at present. We have no means of Knowing what its dimensions are. It may he formidable or it may be contemptible.

i ence, however, no doubt can This organisation has ad-sod more than one circular letter to foreign newspapers published in the Settlements as well as in the adjacent colonies, and the document, though outspokenly seditious, has been published verbatim by the journals receiving it Further, some of the leaders of the seditious movement have found asylum within the limits of the Foreign Settlements, and the Chinese Authorities are powerless to effect their arrest without consular wa rants which cannot be obtained. Thus, in a word, the Settlements and the adjacent colonies not only offer a safe refuge to Chinese subjects plotting against the Chinese Government, but also supply public organs for the ventilation of the plotters' ideas. It happens that we are all in sympathy with the plotters. The ends they have in view would greatly benefit their country. hoy are, in fact, endeavouring to obtain the practical recognition of principles which Occidental people endorse heartily and have long advocated as essential to China's being. But in the eyes of Chinese ofticialdom, they are simply rebels; radical, pestilential agitators whose apprehension And punishment are most desirable in the interests of public peace. The Chinese Government, therefore, must find in the events of the time a new rosen for regretting that foreign intercourse was ever forced upon the country. We daresay, also, that at seasons like the present the rulers of the Middle Kingdom wish heartily that neither a Confucius nor a Mencius had existed. For Confucius constructively, and Mencius in the least equivocal terms, laid down the doctrine that a monarch's only title to hold power is hased on his usefulness to his subjects, and that these have an inalienable to depose hin so soon enactments are seen to inure to public injury. There must he thousands upon thousands of devout Confucianists in China who are fully persuaded that to join a movement for the overthrow of the Empress Dowager would he in accords with the not be im weakened by the epithets which certain 1 local journals apply to the Imp.

It would be interesting to know what was the object of the Jupun Mull in publishing this. It says: "We are all in sympathy with the plotters." If so, it would surely have been more sympathetic to say nothing about the plot, if the Mull really thought that a plot existed. But it is very doubtful if there is anything that can be called a "rebellious organisation" in China. A certain; seditious letter has no doubt appeared in some of the foreign newspapers, but it is a mistake to say that it "has been published matin by the journals receiving it," because we received it and declined to publish it. It is very doubtful whether "some of the leaders of the seditious mov ment have found asylum within the limits of the Foreign Settlements, and the Chinese Authorities are powerless to effect their arrest without consular warrants, which cannot be obtained." What the Consuls have done, as we understand it, is to refuse to grant warrants for the arrest of men on such vague charges as the Mail itself makes, insisting that the acetsed must be brought before the Mixed Court and a good primi facie case made out against them. Surely the Nuil is on safer ground when it expresses its belief that the present rulers of China must regret that! Confucius or Mencius ever existed.

We have said that we doubt whether there is any such rebellious organisation in China as the Mail assumes to exist. There is no rebellion. There are Reformers in Ching who are thoroughly dissatisfied with the usurpation of the supreme ower by the Empress Dowager they have the sympathy of a number of the officials; and they are emphatically not rebels, because their agitation, if they are agitating at all, is on_behalf of their rightful Emperor, H. M. Kuang Hsi." The Foreign Ministers at Peking showed how they regarded the situation by their demand to be received in audience by the Emperor and the Emperor alone, and by farther in-, sisting that the visit of their wives to the Empress Dowager was} urely a social event, and had no political significance; and the Go-' vernment itself, through the organs of its Russian friends, has clearly stated that there is no truth in the statement that H. M. Kuang Hsii has been deposed. All the Empress Dowager has done is to select heir for him, as he has no children, The Empress Dowager of course intended to depose him, but she was deterred by the attitude of the provinces, of those very men whom the Jupan Mail stigmatised as rebels, As long as H.M. Kuang Hsi is alive, the Reformers cannot be rebels. As we mentioned some time ago, those among them who are sticklers for form have been particularly anxious that he should not die, fearing that his death might make them rebels. But as so far there is no sedition, it is evident that the Foreign Settlements cannot rightly be called "Nurseries of Sedition."

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account