The Archive · 1901

Mr. J. C. Hanson (Messrs. Dowdall

XXXIV

Manson and McNeill) appeared in the absence of Mr. McNeill; Mr. W. 5. Levo-sin, Acting Secretary to the Municipal Council, was also present; and Mr. Hol comb represented the defendants, In delivering judgment, his Honour said that he was asked to dismiss this ease for tro reasons. The first reason was that the intention of the Ratepayers was not properly carried out in enforcing Resolutjon V. He did not see the validity or strength of that reason.

This was not a suit to determine the amount of license but to punish Dunning for, as alleged, vio~ ing Byelaw 34. If they granted for rgument's sake that the Regulation had not been properly carried out so that the classification was void, or that there were no different classes of licenses, that would not follow that anybody could sell liquor without a license fee. On the contrary, if the contention of the counsel for the defence was true that the classification being had there was no license fee, then no one could sell liquor in Shanghai, 'The second reason urged for the dismissal of the case was that the allegations of the complaint had not been proved. He was not going to decide this case from hearsay' or gossip nor from general knowledge, unless that general knowledge was shown in Court, but he going to decide it*exactly from the facts before him, Tt was pleaded here that the sale of the bottle of whisky was made in No. 9, Nanking Rond at the specific sum of one dollar, and that the sale was made by Drunning or an employe of his. The entire case rested upon the testi-many of Arthur Moore. It was not stated that defendants had no license. Arthur Moore had testified that he went into the thob of defendants and bought four articles, for which he paid a gross sum. He also testified that ho did not ask the specific cost of each article. In order to convict " person of selling liquor it must be shown that the sale of Jiquor actually took place. No evidence had been brought into that Court to show that there was a sale of liquor in the sense of money being paid to Dunning and Ca. for it.

There was no evidence to show that the $3.15 might not be paid by Moore for the cheese and other groceries. There was no proof shown that the shopman who sold the groceries wasan employe of Dunning and Ca. Moore said he could not identify the man who served him, and therefore no proof Of identification was forthcoming for the beno-fit of the Court. And there was no proof that the liquor was whisky. The bottle had been exhibited in Court, and he (his Hon-cur) had not found the word "whisky " on it. The bottle had not. been opened either after purchase, or in Court. The case must be dismissed.

Mr. Holcomb said that they had hoped that a decision would be given by which at least, the American citizens of Shanghai might be guided in respect to the Bye law under which the summons was taken out against the defendants.

His Honour said, that if this was a ques tion of the classification of liquor sellers and the amount of license to be paid the

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account