To the Editor of the Nonrtu-Cutya Dairy News.
Sm,—I did not intend to ask the court esy of your columns for another paper on the dividing line between the Democratic and Republican parties, but since my Peking Critic" appears in Saturday's as no less a personage than Mr.
in bridge, second Secretary of the United States Legation at Pekins, 1 promise all possible brevity in this sur-in_his rejoinder in Saturday's " News," Mr. Bainbridge would except to certain expressions which were used in replying to his first paper, but ho seemed to forget that when he left his official retreat, to engage in this discussion, he did so with the express declaration that erroneous impressions" wou'd be received from what Thad written, and t imple justice to the public required " correction of my many mis-statements When an antagonist thus heralds his advant into the a and seeks to discredit his adversary in the words quoted, he is powerless to complain at the sulutation he receives, and it is still believed that the notice taken of Mr. Bainbridge was fully deserved, and that there has been no misapplication of language.
In the calm and quiet retreat of the nation at Peking, where ho is free from the cares of life and undisturbed Bainbridge by the sounds of 2 moving world, Mr.
might deliver his instruetions toa "cosmopolitan public," on constitutional questions, in a more philoso-phe spirit and not wishing to emphasize his conclusions by references ty battles, which are alike the pride and sorrow of the American people, and which converted country, as it were, into a graveyard ry. Ata time when the problems ilisttion are confronting the whole Saxon race, those in high places ought to be careful not to revive memories point to a division of that race, and calculated to excite sectional should ju the merican. since the formation of the Constitution, two political schools of constructionists, and each school has arrayed itself under the banner of the one or the other of the two political parties; and it may be well for the safety of the government that it is so. On each side are men of eminent attainments and of equal loyalty and patriotism, but the leaders of the Democratic party have never doubted that the government of the United States was a Federal Republic, and this because there certainly was no Central Government until the representatives of the thirteen original States assembled in convention and framed the Constitution, to which the Central Government owes its origin. Suppose there was no Constitution, would not sovereignty reside where it resided before the existence of the Constitution, and would not that be with the people of each State Without the Constitution there could he no American citizens! one could only be the citizen of a State; ud who can vote for President or con-grossman at a national election, except qualified elector residing ina State and qualified by the laws of that state only, vote?
Mr. Bainbridge admits that the Articles As to, of Confederation were a league between the the value of this testimony, and as to' States, and that those Articles conferred which would confer on the rent adleqttite powes to the States or the tive asa Constitution' unless ratified by the States, and this is made to" clew for doubt by the seventh article to the Constitutis which T copy, word for word, as folios "The ratification of the Conventions shall he suttieient for the tion between the ratifying the States sone." In another paper it was stated that all of the thirteen States did not ratify the Constitution when first sub-that it was held to be binding only on ates ratifying it, thus prov jing that it was the act of the States, through their own conventions, which yave 1fe and vitality to the instrument; and how is the Constitution now amended Certainly by the action of the States, and what becomes of the Bainbridye National government when its power to amend the constitution is limited to recommendation only, which a State government may accept or reject But I place before the reader the evidence of " disinterested witness, James Bryce, the author of "The American Commonwealth." After describing the forms of y.vernments of many of the republics of antiquity, Mr, Bryce says:
the American Federal Republic cot responds to none of these forms. It. is itself a commonwealth as well as a union of commonwealths. The States are not mere creatures of the national government, like the counties of England or the departments of France. They have over thei ens an authority which is their own, and not delegated by the Central Government, They have not been called into being by the government. They existed before it. They could exist without it." (Vol. 1, page 18).
Mr. Bainbridge may say that the d cisions of the Supreme Court are belter evidence than the opinion of Mr. Bryce, but if he will examine the Commercial and Financial Chronicles of 7th April, 1900, he will find a report of the case of the State Texas against the Waters-Pierce Oil Company, and in which the Supreme Court decides that the laws of Texas are supreme within that State and cannot be interfered with by the Courts of the United Si decisi ich sustains Mr. Bryce and is atest delivered by the Supreme Court, any previous conflicting decision must yield.
But there yet remains the very highest authority to disprove the contention of Mr. Bainbridge and sustain Mr. Bryce, and it is the Constitution itself. The tenth amendment to the Constitution reads as follows: The powers not delegated to the United States by the
States, are reserved to the States respec-Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the tively, or to the people." Language could not be plainer, nor meaning more explicit, and Mr. Bainbridge will hardly deny that an amendment is as much " part of the Constitution as any article in the body of the instrument, for such denial would nullify the Lith and 15th amendments, which make any negro and coolie in the United States the equal of the Saxon, {amendments which Mr. Bainbridge and his republican associates engrafted upon the Constitution, and of which they ought to be ashamed. ' And has Mr. Bainbridge forgotten that the minority of states refusing to ratify said amendments, were denied representation in congress until they did ratify them which could not be
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.