The Archive · 1901

Mencius on Education

(Written for the "North-China Daily News.)

Theoretically, in China, education held in high esteem; so is one's health. Yet as any fool can hang out a sign board, and thereupon proceed to cure bodily ailments, so any blunderer who knows a few Chinese characters can open a school, and teach what he knows and much that he does not know. Milton once wrote: "Education of youth is not a bow for every man to shoot in that counts himself a teacher, but will require sinews almost: equal to those which Homer gave to Ulysses." But Chinese educationalists never read Milton, and probably for some time yet will have to forego that bracing exer-rise. Wo said that "theoretically" the schoolmaster is a man of importance. He is. "Heaven having produced the inferior people, appointed for them rulers and teachers, with the purpose that they should be assisting God and therefore distinguish ed them throughout the four quarters of the empire." Here, then, teachers hold 2 divine commission, and stand side by side with kings and emperors. They are, moreover, God's viceregents to assist him in caring for the welfare of the masses of the people. It must be admitted that the teacher stands here on a lofty pedestal, and is supported by all the prestige that is supposed to be associated with a divine commission. The present wooden system which for long centuries has in China supplied the place of a rational education would have had little support from Men-dus, His first demand a thorough alliciency. He said: " i, ift teaching men to shoot, made it a rule to draw tue bow to the full, and his pupils also did the same, A master workman, in teaching others, uses the compass and the square and his pupils do the same." This con crete example is only typical of his demands on the resources of those whose duty it is to teach others. He must know "tothe full," and at the same time he must avail' himself of all available re~ sources, in order to lead forth the powers of those under his direction. Weak men would not find much support from him. One is reminded of the words of Mr. Gladstone: But such men are rare; they are not less rare than are great men in any other walk of life. Speaking ge.crally, the work of teaching is, even when pursued with the whole heart, even when felt to be an absorbing work, but >voder-ately successful, while he who teaches with but half his heart, does not really teach at all." It is worthy of notice that the modern Baconian method of education was understood by Mencius, and inculcated by him, more than two millenniums ago. Mencius said: " All who speak about the nature of things have im fact only their phenomena to reason from, and the value of a phenomenon is in its being natural. What I dislike in your wise men is their boring out their conclusions. If those wise men would only act as Vu ad when he conveyed away the waters, there would be nothing to dislike in their wis dom. The manner in which Vu conveyed away the waters, was by doing what gave them ' no trouble. If your wise men would also do that which gave them no trouble, their knowledge would also be great." Dr. Legge rightly remarks that: Mencius here points out correctly the path to knowledge. The rule which he lays down is quite in harmony with that of Bacon."

So, then, Mencius would entrust the important work of directing the young, only to those who were able and willing to teach with all their powers, and the methodg which be would adopt were in complete harmony with modern views.

There is an interesting deliverance, which points out that a father!:2cl1 not teach his own son—daughters are forvetten or disregarded. When asx why ° Superior Man," who is, of course, well fitted for the task, docs not teach his own son, Men-dus replied: "The circumstances of the case forbid its being done. The teacher must inculcate what is correct. When he inculcates what is correct, and his lessons are not practised, he follows them up with being angry. When he follows them up by being angry, then, contrary to what should be, he is offended with his son. At the same time, the pupil says:'My master inculcates in me what is correct, and be himself does not proceed in a correct path!' The result of this is, that father and son are offended with each other. When father and son come to be offended with each other, the case is evil. The an-dents exchanged sons, and one taught the son of another."

From this paragraph it is obvious that anger and the rod are considered essential to an effective teacher, and in this regard modern teachers excel. A very elementary knowledge of Chinese schools makes this fact painfully convincing. This being so when father and sou are " offended with" each other, there would be a serious breach of that dignified respect with which the son regards his parent, and this correct relationship would be endangered.

Tt may be stated that schools and colleges have existed in China from time immemorial, if the words of Mencius can be relied upon. It is not necessary here to quote the passage, but Mencius certainly assumes that higher-grade schools, called Hou, were existing in the capital and other large cities of the empire, and that elementary schools called by' different names were to be found in the smaller owns and villages, from the very beginning of the national life of Chinese. It is assumed indeed that they were established during the times of the His dynasty (B.C. 22051766). Most Europeans who have written on these times have maintained that these ages are either legendary or only semi-historical, and therefore we cannot accept the statements of the Sage. But what is of interest to us is, that he assumes that two grades of education were in existence then, and that therefore he would support this idea as the correct one. We indeed in the West have come to regard education as element tary, middle, and higher. Mencius would content himself with an elementary education for the masses, and a liberal edueation for the classes.' Here again, theory tically, this standard is the modern one among ese.

The range of subjects taught in the days of Mencius was, as far as Tam aware, not an extensive one, and has not been defin~ itoly outlined by him. Rife educated man should acquire a mastery over his own language, the history of his own country archery, ceremonies, etiquette, and the five relationships. Of such subjects as astronamy, mathematics, geography, ete., he appears to have been ignorant, and consequently the Chinese have paid no attention to these things, throughout their entire history. OF course, the Jesuits taught the elements of some of these sciences, but they have never entered into the educational system of the nation.

The object of an education was eminently utilitarian. It was that men might have a comfortable subsistence, and also understand the ordinary duties connected with the relationships of life. "The minister of Agriculture taught the people to sow and reap, cultivating the five kinds of grain. When the five kinds of grain were brought to maturity the people all enjoyed a comfortable subsistence. Now men possess a moral nature; but if they are well fed and warmly clad and comfortably lodged, without being taught at the same time, they become almost like the beasts. This was a subject of anxious solicitude to the sage Shun, and he appointed Seo to be the Minister of Instruction, to teach the relations of humanity." He also insisted that the aim of an education should be to ensure that the "student should be filial, obedient to the elders, true-hearted and faithful." This perhaps approaches, though it does not reach the object of a liberal education as outlined by Ruskin.

"Education is the leading human. souls to what is best, and making what is best of them. The training which makes men happiest in themselves also makes them most serviceable to others." We ungrudgingly recognise that in these statements Mencius has Laid down a noble aim, and it is much to be regretted that the system when worked out lias so woefully failed to accomplish this result. Nor would he lower his standard to meet the objections of the captions, the incapacity of the weak, and the indifference of the idle. Kung-Sun-show said: "Lofty are your princi ples and admirable, but to learn them may be well likened to ascendii

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account