9th June.
Mr. Arnoup Wuite has sent us a pamphlet entitled " Society, Smart Society, and Bad Smart Society: Their Influence on Empire, being seven letters written to the Editor of the Daily Chronicle." the letters, published after Mr. Mas: ingham had resigned the editorship of the "Daily Chronicle," there is an editorial note which says: "It must be understood that while we willingly give: Mr. Arnold White the publicity of- our columns: for his interesting series of letters, we do not endorse all the views he express As Mr. Arnold White's view of Society in England much resembles that taken by Ouida in her novel "'The Massereenes," and adopted in such papers as "Truth" and the "Investors' Review," this note was perhaps not unnecessary. On the other hand, one of our great empire-builders who passed through Shanghai recently attributed some of our reverses in South Africa to the fact that our Generals are selected by the "smart women" in London, and Mr. reve: the great surgeon, has quite recently described the plague that these smart women have been, and probably' still are, in South Africa.
A few extracts from Mr, White's letters will certainly be of interest even to those who consider his strictures too severe; but it is the duty of the satirist to lay his colours on thickly. In his opening letter, dated the 30th of January of thi year and headed " 'Society' and the Work of the Empire," Mr. White says that everybody is waiting for the opening of Parliament, but there is no desire to displace the Government, because there is no alternative Cabinet ready, and the sting Government is responsible for the condition into which affairs have got. Mr. White goes on to say The present calamities are not due to the action of any public department or section of a department in which employment, is open to all comers duly qualified. The commissariat, the army medical staff, the company officers, the private soldiers, the Army Service Corps, and the transport department have done splendidly. There has been no failure in connection with any ranch of the public service open to the public. The scandal and breakdown have resulted from the departments where the stati is chosen entirely from a small and privileged caste. Smart society has captured the Foreign Office, one side of the War Office, the cavalry, avd the higher military appointments.
"What are the results?; In foreign affairs on those matters of detail in which the overworked Premier and Foreign Secretary cannot be expected to interfere England has been hosted whenever she has come into conflict with foreign Powers. The seizure of the Bundesrath and other German steamers, on false information, and their subsequent surrender under the humiliation of threats from Berlin, should have been impossible if the Foreign Office were organised on plain business principles, and worked by men who lost their billets if they wore stupid or idle, instead of being assured of pensions the more stupid and the more incapable they showed themselves {tol In the ne manner the British Army, jin its hi riches, is a great social jrather_ th ting machine. The Queen's uniform, that should be a source pride, while compulsory on the private, is "bad form" on the officer off duty. The Germans do not thus regard the ques-To one of tion—nor do the Boers.
Without going into more detail, is it not a fact that the ornamental privileged caste among our rulers hws hopelessly failed to justify i monopoly of certain branches of the public service, and that, therefore, if this war is not only to be won, but our national safety assured og nities, English ciemoeracy must reclaim the power with which they have parted, and by silent, peaceful revolution insist on fitness and efficiency becoming the one qualification for public employment In the Navy this is the rule to a large Jextent, and hence alone our national safety.
Asan earnest of our resolve to national-ise the services, it is needful that men ko Mr. H. Chaplin, Lord Lansdowne, and Lord Cross should be replaced by men with brain power, organising capacity, and business experience, Mr. White's second letter, dated {the Qnd of February, is headed "Where Smart Society Meddles," and shows how good men have been passed over because they were not popular yin the smart set. He instances Sir Charles Warren, Sir F. Carrington (who has shown his value by relieving Mafeking with such almost incredible celerity), and Lord Charles Beresford. He then tells us something about the rumoured relief of Ladysmith, which was, it will be remembered, tele-a fact.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.