Robinson (instructed by Messrs. Dennys and Bowley) appeared for the plaintiffs, und Mr. J. J. Francis, QC, and the Hon. H. E. Pollock (instructed by Messrs, Johnson, Stokes and Muster) for the defendants,
jury:—Messrs. G. Moxon (foreman), C. W.
The following composed the special Dixon, E. W. Mitchell, a. Bubington, C.
Inchbald, 'T. I. Rose and G. P. Lammert.
Mr. Robinson read the pleadings of the case as follows:
Petition (dated May 3rd, 1899):—*(1)—The plaintiffs carry on business at Amoy,
chants under the style or firm name of Kin Ching, a8 general import and export mer-Cheong, and at other places under the style or firm name of Wing Cheong; they also carry on business as bankers under the style or firm name of Fat Ki, and also the business of ten merchants under the style or firm name of Yau Ki. (2)—The defendant company is n marine insurance company with limited liability, duly registered such in the colony of Hongkong, having its head office in Hongkong and agend in Amos, Tientrin, and other places."
about the 21st October, 1898, the plain-tit insured with the defendant company goods to the value of $40,000 to be shipped at Tientsin in China on the Danish steamship Activ on her then next voyage from Tientsin to Amoy via Newchwang, Chefoo, and Tameui, (4)—On or about the Slat October, 1898, the pi further insured with the defendant company goods to the value of $4,318.34 to be shipped at Tientain on board the aforesaid steamer Activ upon the aforesaid voyage from Tientsin to Amoy vin Newchwang, Chefoo, ant Tamsui. (5)—Goods of the plaintiff of the value of the aforesaid sums of $40,000 and of $4,318.34 were duly shipped on board the aforesaid steamer Activ at Tien arriage on bourd the aforesaid steamer on the aforesaid voyage, but the said steamer and all the ods £0 insured as aforesaid were on or about the 9th November, 1398, totally lost whilst on the aforesaid voyage' off the port of Tamsui by the perils insured against, (G)—All things have happened, all cond tions have been fulfilled, and all times have elapsed necessary to entitle the plaintiffs to recover in full from the defendant company the aforesaid several sums of $40,000 and $4,818.34 respectively, but the defendant company has neglected and refused to pay the same. The plaintiffs therefore pray—(1)—A decree that the defendant company pay the plaintiffs the said sums of $40,000 and $4,316.34 respectively together with interest thereon todate of payment. (2)—The plaintifly costs of this suit. (8)—Such other and further relief as to the Court may seem meet and the circumstances of the case require."
Answer (dated June 20th, 1899)—" (1)—The defendants admit the statements in the first, 9 third and fourth para: graphs of the petition to be true. (2)—In answer to the 5th paragraph of the petition the defendants admit that the said steamer Activ with all the goods then laden on board of her were on or about the 9th voyage off the port of Tamsui by the perils insured against, but they deny that goods to the value of $44,318.34 or to anything like that value were shipped on board the said steamer delly at Tientsin for carriage on board of the said steamer Activ at Tientsin to be carried on the said voyage or anyhow. (3)—The defendants further say answer to the 5th paragraph, that the goods shipped on board of" the ssid 8s, Activ at Tientsin to be carried on the said voyage were not of the value of $44,318.34 or more than $28,539.33, and were at the time of the suid insurances overvalued by the plaintiffs with the intention of defrauding the defendants. (4)—In reply to paragraph 6 of the petition the defendants say that the plaintiffs are not entitled to recover from the defendants the id sums of $10,000 and $4,318.34 or any sum or sums and admit that they, defendants, have refused to pay the same, (5)—In the alternative the defendants bring here into Court the sum of twenty-nine thousand three hui that thesame is sufficient to satisfy the plaintiff? claims herein whether for principal or interest."
Replication (dated 17th August, 1899)
(1)—The plaintiffs deny the allegations of fraud contained in the third paragraph of the defendants' answer. (2) The plaintiffs join issue upon all and every of the allegation or allegations contained in the defendants? answer save in 40 fur as the same consist of admissions of the allegations in the plainti petition. (3) And the plaintifis further say that the goods insured with the defendant company a4 in the petition alleged and in the answer admitted were insured at an ageeed value of $40,000, and 3,000 Tiewt sin taels under valued policies.
Rejoinder (dated September 12th, 1899.—"(1)—The defendants deny that the goods or any of the goods insured with them were insuced ut an agreed value of $40,000 and 3,000 Tientsin taels or either of such values or at aus ageeed value whatever either under valued policies or otherwise. (2.) In the alternative the defendants say that, even if the said goods or any of them were insured aten agreed value (which the defendants deny), the plaintiffs overvalued such goods with intent to defraud the defendants, and accoriugly that either the plaintifis are entitled to recover nothing under the said insurances from the defendants or else that any valuation of any of the said goods must be wholly set aside."
Mr. Drummond said that since the plead-13s hind been closed he found that the issues ad been decided by his Lordship in chambers. These issues he proposed to read before addressing his Lordship with reference to the law. 'The issues were:—*(1) Were the goods in the piendings mentioned insured With the defendant company by the plaintitts at an agreed value of $40,000 and Tientsin, fuels 3,000, as is alleged in the plaintiffs' replication? (2) Were goods to the value of $4,318,34, or thereabouts, shipped by the plaintitts at Tientsin' on board of the s. Activ, or were the goods shipped by the piaiutif at Tientsin on board of the activ of the value of $28,539, or thereabouts, or what other valu the goods shipped by the plainti said were over-valued, was such over-valuation made with intent to defraud the defendant company? (4) Ifthe said goods were over-valued with intent to defraud the defendant company, does such fraud so vitiate the insurance as to release the defendant company altogether from any liability to the plaintills? (5) It the suid goods were over-valued with intent to defraud the defendant company, are the plaintiffs nevertheless entitled to recover and take out of Court the money paid in by the defendants?" Continuing, Mr. Drummond said it appeared to him that sues one, four, and five were the issues for the Court and issues two and three were the issues practically for the jury to decide. He thought his Lordship would probably
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.