The Archive · 1900

THE CHINESE CRISIS; ITS CAUSES, AND HOW TO REMOVE THEM

4th Dec. Many and diverse are the explanations of the causes which led up to the anti-Foreign movement and the Boxer troubles, and all are of a more or less unsatisfactory nature, inasmuch as each is one only of a concatenation of circumstances. Some blame the missionaries and their intemperate, After the hardships and excitements narrow-minded and ill-advised action in backing up native desperadoes simply because they happen to be so-called converts or Christians. Be that as it may, it was not the cause. Others attribute the outbreak to the action of Germany in seizing Kiaochou, and their subsequent treatment of the coolies working under them. Even were these stories of German ill-treatment in a general sense true, which they are not, would such incidents have started a Boxer movement many hundred miles from the scene? It takes little strain on the imagination to say "impossible." Then we hear the trouble attributed to the foreign traveller who rides through the country in a tight-fitting coat and rifle slung over the shoulder. Was ever an explanation more absurd? Anyone who knows the Chinese will at once recognise that the attitude of the Celestial rustic is anything but one of ill-feeling at the sight of such things as tight-fitting coats and rifles, which'arouse their curiosity more than any other feeling. They think much of the man who owns anything a little beyond their comprehension. And this is particularly the case with the Western Shantung man. Then we hear of the explainers attributing the outbreak solely to the action of Russia—massing troops to protect her railway in construction. Here again there is a mistake; for although the behaviour of the Russian troops prior to the break-out of trouble was anything but that of a civilised nation, yet even they were not the initiatory cause.

The best way to seek an explana~ tion is to seek a parallel. Some there may be who will say that such is impossible; but they are wrong if what is sought is a parallel to the initial cause. Such a parallel, curious as it may seem, may be found by looking at the history of Ireland during that dark period of land agitation and agrarian outrage ox-tending from 1870 to 1885, There you had a number of political agitators whose livelihood depended on preventing enlightenment from reaching; the poor and uneducated class, an on the principle that a little knowledge is a dangerous thing, they took advantage of every grievance, real or imaginary, utilised these for all the; were worth to get rid of or exterminate the "Foreign Devil" (in that case the Anglo-Saxon landlord). Wherein lies the parallel? It is here: the troubles in China, or rather North China, can be directly attributed to the political agitators in power, who are designated by the names Manchus and mandarins. Dreading the possibility of enlightenment reaching the lower or coolie class and rustics through the energies of the Reform Party and the missionary and contact with the foreigner, and knowing that such enlightenment spells the death-knell of their own existence as a ruling body and does away with their chances of squeeze, they have looked round for every cause that could be made use of for their purpose. As Parnell obtained his tools from the gutter, so the Manchus and mandarins have obtained the instruments of agitation and disorder from the lowest of the low in Chinese life; beggars, robbers, unemployed, brawlers, and the like were just the material to work upon and the instruments to accomplish their ends, Circumstances, as often happens, lent their aid, Many Chinese had, through contact with foreigners, developed more luxurious tastes than those they formerly possessed, and had grown to like the "chow" which usually adorned the table of the foreigner. Then the north, and particularly Shantung and Eastern China,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account