Ly March 1899 a paper with the above title, written by Mr. G. M. H. Playfair, H. M. Consul at Foochow, was read ata meeting of the Manchester Geographical Society. The question in the minds of us all is: What is to become of China? Any contribution to the solution of that question is welcome, especially soa contribution from one who knows China and the Chinese so well as Mr. Playfair. He begins by accepting the description of China as " the sick man of the Far East." " Here we have an empire huge of bulk, a very Falstaff of a country, yet so devoid of energy, strength, and aparently of resources, that we have seen it fall prostrate, almost without a struggle, at the feet of a race with only a tithe of its population, and which it had for centuries boastfully despised." Mr. Playfai 5 commends the resolution with which Japan grasped the nettle, notes Lord Wolseley's mistaken idea of the value of China as an ally, and the German Emperor's exaggerated conception of the "Yellow Peril." "That China," he says, "should ever become the scourge of Western civilisation 18, we trust, fully recognised since 1895 to be an impossibility. ill it must be admitted that, so "prolific is the race, so adapted to survive by its alities of toil and_ thrift," that hina, whatever be her political destiny, is fated to remain an ineffuceable geographical expression. Her 400 millions (or 300 millions, whichever it may be) are never going to be improved off' the face of the earth, as it happened to the Red Indians and the Maoris."
Mr. Playfair remarks again on the mistake Europe has made in turning so much attention to Africa, when China is such a much more' promising field. He classes as porary expedients" the acquisi by Foreign Powers of Kiaochou Bay, Port Arthur, Talienwan, Weihaiwei, and Kuangchouwan. " Specific leases of territory and definition of spheres' will only serve to stave off the evil day. The day of reckoning is approaching, and the questions of the hour are: Must China yield to outside pressure and consent to be dismembered?' or, 'Should she resist?' If to the latter we give an affirmative reply, a subsidiary enquiry presents itself: Can she do so with any chance of success To which the only answer is: As she is at present circumstanced, she certainly cannot. Then, is it feasible so to strengthen her that she will ever find it possible?" Mr.
it shows how the decadence of China has been going on for years. "She has been shorn seriatim of all her subject States—Burma, Annam, Formosa, Corea, all have gone. Part of Kirin helped to round off Russian possessions years ago, and of the fate of the remainder of Manchuria there is little cause to doubt. Part of Ili went; more may very well follow. Tibet alone remains." The trank, Mr. Playfair says, is now menaced, and what we have to consider at present is 1.—Is it to our advantage to preserve the integrity of China?
2.—If this ought to be done, are we the nation that ought to do it?
3.—How should we, in that case, set about it The first question Mr. Playfair answers in the affirmative on the ground that our trade must suffer from the annexation of any part of China by a Power which may and probably will sooner or later impose differential duties.
The second question he also answers in the affirmative. Mr. Playfair asserts that our prestige with the Chinese as a people who may be trusted to do what is right and never go back on their word, is as high as ever, perhaps higher than ever. "Other Powers may be feared—undoubtedly they are—and they may succeed in wringing concessions from China by playing' on the feeling; but Great Britain is the one country which can in such concessions through nothing but good will.... On this ground alone we are the proper nation to undertake the strengthening of China. The foremost qualification a successful physician needs is the gift of inspiring confidence in his patients. This qualification we possess." The attitude of the Yangtze Viceroys and other high Chinese officials during the present crisis is the best proof that could be needed that Mr. Playfair is right in his answer to this second question. The Chinese have confidence in us.
Then comes the third, the crucial question how we are to set about preserving the integrity of China. In the first place, China is ignorant of her own strength. She is a self-sufficing country, and the first thing to be done is to teach her to develop her own resources. Before this, however, must come the recasting of the whole machinery of government. By this Mr. Playfair means that "there must be for every province
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.