The Archive · 1900

The Fighting Value of Fanaticism

NoTWITHSTANDING

knowledge we have of the claims of; the Boxers to miraculous powers and invulnerability, have been, intensely surprised at the audacity shown in their attacks on Admiral Seymour and in Tientsin. Why, with our wealth of experience much matters, we Britis..ers should have been astonished, it is difficult to say. The fanatic is no stranger to us. We have met him in Afghanistan, in the Soudan, on the shores of the Red Sea, and amongst the mountains of the N. W. Frontier. He has opposed his assegai to our lance in South Africa, he has taught us caution in New Zealand. All the world over we are old friends. Why we are surprised now is not that, being a fanatic, the Boxer fights well, but that, being a Chinaman, he really believes in his supernatural claims. In short, we are taken aback to find that he is a fanatic at all. Had we recognised him from the beginning, there would have been no mistake. We usually keep harsh terms for those who don't agree with us, and so just as orthodoxy-is our doxy and heterodoxy other people's doxy, so our belief is faith, and our foe's fanaticism. There may be no fundamental difference between them and hence definition is easy. Fanaticism is the exhibition on the battlefield of a bravery on the pact of our enemies to which they have no natural claim. When we show it, it is pluck, but that's quite a different thing. A century of experience has, however, taught us to respect even fanaticism. Have we not watched some of the ugly rushes it can make, rushes which sweep aside professional maxims as a whirlwind scatters the dust? Your true fanatic as a soldier has no equal but one of his own kind. He wants neither food nor rest; to him, danger is a lure, and death no deterrent. Fear is unknown, failure an impossibility. By and by the world will offer up thanksgiving, and sing Te Deums for other things than the surrender of a few hundred Boer farmers. They will recognise the, at present, unheeded fact, that, providentially, so far there has arisen no well-taught and well-supplied army of fanatics. What might have been the result to Egypt and to Europe if the hordes of the Soudan, who wiped out Hicks Pasha and his army, who nearly repeated the performance with Baker, who broke at least one British square, and inspired Thomas Atkins with a high respect for them, what, we repeat, might hate been the result bad they been able! to shoot like the Boers, drill like the Germans, and draw upon unlimited resources like the British Luckily, hitherto, rank fanaticism has always been on the weaker side—not necessarily weaker in number, but in power as at Omdurman—and being so, has ever been worsted by superior knowledge and better arms. Wherever it has been found in more equal combats, as for instance in those of the rebellion in the time of Charles I, fanaticism has carried everything before it. We are unaccustomed to hear Cromwell's Ironsides thus disrespectfully spoken of, but spades are call th ades, by whatever names we em. Havelock's Saints in the Indian Mutiny were invincible frown the same cause. Many people, English peo to see ple too, were quite prepared ultimate triumph of the Boer, because Boer and Bible were so frequently found in conjunction. But the fundamental error in such characterization lay in the inability of these British people to note one quality which the Boer possesses that is always absent from your true fanatic The latter never calculates: the former always does, frequently making errors in the i recess. He figures out to no small amount the value of his own precious skin. lo measures his distances, and, well covered behind the rocks on his kopje, he says, "When the enemy shows on the top of yon hill, I open on him with shrapnel; when reaches di he line of bushes he'll be warmly welcomed with case and magazine fire; when he gets to the bottom of this hill, I shall look round for my horse; when I see his helmet over the rise there, I shall bolt." This may be wisdom, but it is not fanatic cism. The Mohammedan's paradise is so alluring that he wants to get there, the Boer's so dubious that he prefers life on the veldt. This is one reason why he so seldom attacks. He who counts the cost will never lead a charge. To your trae fanatic there is but one word, " Forward," one idea, "The enemy—how can I get at him." Of the three stages in every fight, the "funk" stage, the fighting stage, and the fanatic stage, the last, to him, is the only one worth living for and dying in. He hears, but does not heed, the thud with which a bullet finds its billet, with no more reason than the charging steed he rushes onward, and none but steady troops can stop his mad career.

Luckily for the civilised world, the fanatic is seldom versed either in military history or in the science of war. "We are, however, trying to engraft such knowledge upon the individual fanatics of which every army has its share. Modern, civilised fanaticism has, however, mote of fame than fane mit. B.~P.'s desire to be put into d hot corner was, perhaps, partly of this type. Sometimes it springs from patriotism, sometimes from esprit de corps. The vision of a V.C. or the desire for a D.S.O. has just that stimulating effect which leads reckless men into deeds of daring valour. The motive is ditferent, the end the same. Wolseley in his "Pocket Book" advocates as a duty the cultivation of this spirit of self-sacrifice in the soldier.

One thing, however, is certain. The spirit of fanaticism, under whatever name we know it, is not cultivable in any army unless it'leads to success. Particularly is this true of the undisciplined. 'I'he Boxer was intoxicated with his triumph in shutting the Ministers in Peking, and Admiral Seymour out of it. He lost men, but what of that: men are cheap in China. In his eyes the plight to which he reduced Admiral Seymour's party was a signal success to his arms. Then came the attacks on Tientsin. They, too, were at first promising enough, thanks to the "fanaticism" of the attack. But the later conflicts have told a different tale. Two or three more such, and the Boxer with his trained allies will be "on, the run" never to stand again, much less to assault, The one food on which fanaticism can feed and live has been He denied. Without the constant success of the great Napoleon its collapse is rapid and complete.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account