To the Editor of the "No am-Unixa Datty News."
Sir,—That the negotiators of a public instrument should fail to state their meaning in terms clear enough to be comprehended by the man in the street, not to speak of such intelligent critics as Mr. Cecil Holliday, is surely a grave reflection on their capacity for lucid pression, and it is with a view to end Your to remove some misapprehension: with regard to the published text of the new Commercial Treaty that I venture to encroach upon your space. Let mo deal with Mr, Holliday's criticisms seriatim.
Article XI. Whether or not, when China herself shall have put. down the cultivation of the poppy within her own borders, the British Government will consent to a prohibition of the impor tion of opium, Iam not prepared to say, but as regards morphia they acceded to China's request that some preventive measures be adopted to check the growth of this insidious evil which is spread so rapidly amongst the poorer class Hongkong does not close her doors to opium, but has in the interests of the Chinese populace had to legislate against Article XII. Mr. Holliday confines himself to three notes of exclamation presumably indicative of his intense astonishment that Great Britain would lever dream of surrendering lier extraterritorial rights even did China's administrative methods become more xdvanced than those of any South American ublic in which the British trader is loft to wrestle with native anarchy and corruption as best he can. China is essentially the country of laissez aller, and when, in the fulness of time, it may seem good to the British Government to recognise China as a full-fledged member of the comity of nations, the Dritish subject is less likely to be interfered with than he is now under the bureaucratic methods of the Continent, adopted by our allies the Japanese.
Article XIIT. The Protocol provides for the revision of existing Commercial Treaties. The Treaty of Tientsin contains a religious clause, why should a reference to religion read quaintly in an agreement revising that Treaty Article VIII. Mr. Holliday fails to recopniso that this Article is really a Treaty within a Treaty. Should the Treaty as a whole be ratified by Great Britain, it comes, as far as Great Britain is concerned, into force at once—all but Article YILT, which has to avait the concurrence of the other Treaty Poxei Pending or failing their adhesion thereto, likin and other internal taxation continue as before, and provision had therefore to be made to enable the rest of the Treaty to stand, so to speak, on its own bottom. Hence the allusion to likin in Article TIS. and the reiteration of the opening of Kongmoon in Article X.
Mr. Holliday in his first objection to the terms of Article VIII says that while transit likin is placed in the foreground other "dues" are only mentioned casually. This is not correct. The two systems of internal taxation, transit likin and other dues at place of production or destination are always mentioned together, as witness the wording of Section 2 of Article VIII which provides that the payment of the tax is to compensate for "the aboli-of likin, of transit dues in liew of likin, and of all other taxation on foreign goods." Mr. Holliday does not seem to be aware of the fact that in addition to transit likin, there is destination and grower's likin which under certain cir-posts by H.M.'s Government.
Mr. Holliday asserts that the British wemment gets out of the surtax a definite fund "on which to come down for the interest, ete., on the Indemnity due to itself and its mends." Having studied the Treaty with so that Dir. Holliday has not given equal attention to the Annexes, for in he would have found that the Bri Government does not intend to enrich itself and its friends ai British trade. He would als therein have found the methods of allocate he surtax to the Provincial authorities, point for which the Association, of which ihe is a member, has always strenuously contende Mr. Holliday states that the people China do not come into this show at all." What i, the foundation jor such a statement They obtain absolute freedom of circulation for their commodities with out any of the {delays hitherto camp! regards the Consumption Tax ch te wn} will be ry well able, through its gr.ilds or trade corporations, to protect itself. As regards this unch cut loised Cop sump. tion Tax, do the critics believe 1 would have been possible by any foreign Treaty to regulate th internal taxation of China!
Mackay's first proposals did dow 1 in that direction when in retura a 15 per cent import duty China was in; sh throughout the
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.