The Archive · 1910

U, 8. COURT FOR CHINA

Shanghai, November 14.

Before the Hon. Roros H. Tuaver, Tadge.

G. 1. SHEKORY 2, F. M. BROOKS, Mr. 8. Fessenden and Mr. G. H.

Wright appeared for the plaintiff and Mr, W. 8. Fleming and Mr. F. M. Brooks for defendant. indemnity in connexion with certain rubber share transactions, for interest and costs, In his amended petition plaintiff set out that be purchased 900 shares in the Anglo-Java Estates, Ld,, for defendant for Jane delivery and also 400 shares in the Sisk Indrapoera Rabber Concessions, Ld., for the same settlement. Plaintiff made himself personally liable for these purchases and was willing, ready and able and offered deliver the aald shares upon payment for them, but defendant refused to take delivery or to assume or accept liability for said purchases.

his answer defendant stated that the transactions mentioned in the petition were ventures la speculation depending for profit or loss on the fluctuation of the market and were wholly gambling transactions, That on the dates mentioned in the petition the defendant took a nominal option from plaintiff on said shares for futare delivery which in fact was fictitious, no delivery being intended nor was same demanded. Defendant furth it was well understood that the transactions were to be settled by the payment of differences; and that if plaintiff sustained any loss or incurred sections, wed or liability was in-any liability by reason of these tran-carred la respect tot gaming or wagering contracts or agreements, and'were wholly void. Defendant also set out that it was mataslly agreed to rescind these contracts on or about Jane 25.

Mr, Fessenden in opening the plaintiff's case said that this was a test case ising out of the present situation in Shanghai with regard to the rabber market. It was the desire of the parties interested in these cases to have test case in each Court 80 a8 to have

decisions were sought in Sha uniform decisions in the The plaintiff alleged that be was stracted by the defendant to purchase certain shares for his account for Jane and this defendant in the first place denied snd then varied his answer by saying that it was " transaction in option, Mr. Fleming ssid that the only issue before the Court was gambling. fendant denied that " ona fide lawful contract was entered into, or any tender to perform was made by him.

Plaintiff was then called. He said that he did not operate to a large extent on the Shanghai Stock Exchange, of which he wasa member, He had no desiings for the March settlement, but there was 'a large business being done for Jape, 50 he took advantage of it s a broker.

Brooks spprosched bim at the Palace Hotel and asked him to bay 200 Siaks for June, saying that he bad sold short and thought that it was time to cover. This was about April 6 or 7. Witness did not know what it was to take " nominal option on shares. Mr. Brooks never used the words " nominal option" when giving witness instructions, neither was anything said about fature eale—defendant led witness to believe that he bad sold short sud desired to cover, Nothing was said about differences. Witness bought 200

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account