The Archive · 1902

The Educational Effort

The energetic efforts that are now being put forth to teach the English language to the Filipinos is provoking a good deal of discussion in the papers. The Manila "American" refers to the matter in the following terms What is going to be the result of the attempt to teach English to the Filipinos is a question that a good many contemlative and philosophic minds here and in the States are considering. It is con-coded that Spanish educational methods were worse than antiquated, and that it was the Church policy to keep the natives in ignorance, yet that after three hundred years only five per cent of the people can read or speak Spanish is a fact that is very convincing. Can we force an Anglo-Saxon language upon a Malay people? Can the conquering race impose its tongue upon the vanquished except through the course of many years of intimate association? Languages. may amalgamate but the utter destruction of one at the expense of another is very rare. It is true that Celtic and Gaelic are about extinct in Ireland and Scotland. but look at the length of time required to cause it. If we succeed in the end in making English the popular tongue, what effect will it have on the mental habits and the social status of the Filipinos? A great authority has said, "The most powerful means of action at the disposal of Europeans—education, institutions, beliefs are absolutely inefficacious as a means of changing the social state of the the inferior peoples." There never was a more altruistic scheme attempted by any of the nations of earth than the sending the "school-master abroad in the land" by the United States Government, and we Americans who are here should lend all possible assistance to it, even for its apparent Quixotism, if for no other reason. Still that need not prevent us feeling that if it succeed the Americans will have wrought a modern miracle. The latest project broached, of sending a band of picked Filipino youths to America for a four years course, has many admirable points connected with it. Four years in an American atmosphere would Surely have a marked effect upon the student, but on the other hand would it not remove them as far from their own people as does Carlyle in the case of the American Indian? The experiment is worth trying, perhaps, if those chosen be widely scattered among the reputable institutions of the United States so that they may be unable to form little colonies of their own.

The Electric Railway Franchise.

The Manila "Freeman" discusses this important subject in the following article The public session of the Civil Commission for the discussion of the act publishing the terms of, and calling for bids on, a franchise for an electric street railway for the municipality of Manila will tal place this forenoon (October 15th). It is understood that there are no great pro-habilities of more than one bid—that of the Filer syndicate. However, the representatives of the latter syndicate are positive in their assertion that, unless the clause granting the power to the municipality to compel the substitution for the overhead trolley of the underground system or other approved conductor or motive power, if practicable, after fifteen years, is removed, the company will not enter a bid for the franchise. The offending clause is as follows:—"Tho system of electric railroad to be installed hereunder by the grantee shall be the overhead trolley system and at any time after fifteen years from the date hereof, the grantee may be required by ordinance or law to remove all of its overhead wires and structures, if practi able, and to substitute therefor underground wires, or other approved conduct for or motive power." At first sight it would not appear that any particular hardship could be worked under this clause, but it is the claim of the Filer people that, sooner than accept this clause they will abandon the scheme entirely. It is their contention that owing to the low level of Manila streets, the underground system will never be practicable here, and that their expert engineers have rendered reports to this effect. They assert that if it can be proven practicable they will accept the terms without further question, and enter a bid for the franchise, but under no other circumstances will they be induced to bid. It is admitted that the underground system is impracticable at the present time, but it is thought by some, and is evident] the opinion of the commission, that it may not be impracticable in the future. However, if the Filer company is right, and thee underground impracticable, no great harm would be done by cutting this clause out. The company does not question that the commission is well-meaning, but disapprove of a power being placed in the hands of the Municipal Board 0, if they sce fit, compel an entire change of system, and thus handicap and injure the service of the company. However, the question should be left to experts to determine, and both the authorities and the company should stand by the decision rendered. It is not the desire of the municipality or of the commission to ask impos es, but we must first be convinced that are impossibilities. The Tobacco Industry, The Manila "Freedom" publishes an appeal from the allied Chambers of Commerce for information regarding the tobacco industry in the Philippines.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account