The Archive · 1902

Alleged Jewellery Swindle

At the Mixed Court on Friday morning, before Mr. Chang (Magi Mr. F. B. Wilkinson (British Assessor). 'a native broker, residing in Honan Road, was charged with obtaining by false pretences pearls to the value of $4.000 from a shop. No. 363, Hankow Road on the 29nd of October.

Inspector Matheson stated that on the 18th of October, the defendant went to the complainant's store and obtained $1.000 worth of pearls on credit. The defendant again went to the store on the 29nd October and obtained more pearls on credit, to the value of $3,000. Shortly afterwards the defendant yawned the pearls for the sum of $2.000. but had never paid the complainant anything.

Dr. Vorwerk said that he had been instructed to appear in the case by Mr. W. J. Andrews, of Messrs. Gande and Ca. He also appeared for the defence. The defendant, who was a broker, obtained the pearls from the complainant with the intention of selling them at a profit. About the same time Mr. Andrews instructed the defendant to sell some valuable books for him. The books were from Peking and were very valuable. Defendant was to have as his commission any surplus that was obtained for the books above a certain figure. The defendant made an agreement for the sale of the books and bargain money was paid. The defendant being in want of ready money and knowing that he would have a considerable sum to draw ax his commission on the sale of the books, pawned the pearls for the sum of $2,000, intending to redeem them when he drew his commission. Before the books were handed over to the purchaser, however, the complainant came round to the defendant's house and took away the books, probably intending to hold them ax security for the value of the pearls. The defendant wax therefore unable to complete the sale of the books and was placed in a very awkward position. The case was not a matter for criminal procedure, but should have been a civil case. The defendant had never refused to pay for the pearls; they were not stolen, and would have been paid for but for the conduct of the complainant.

Inspector Matheson pointed out that the pearls had been pawned for the sum of $2,000, Dr. rerk said that it did not matter for what sum the pearls were pawned. The dant had never refused to pay for Tnspector Matheson said that the defendant had been previously convicted for gambling and swindling.

The Assessor said that the Magistrate ad just referred to that fact.

Dr. Vorwerk said that he had no that that was the case. He his instructions from Mr. Andrews that morning. Mr. Andrews was unable attend the Court himself and had asked him to represent him. Mr. Andrews was afraid that if the defendant was sent to prison the books would not be recovered. Two nights ago the complainant had returned some of the bucks, but had kept back two. He (Dr. Vorwerk) would like the Court to make an order that the remainder of the books should be returned, and that the pearls should either be returned or paid for.

The Assessor said that the complain denied all knowledge of the books. had never had them.

Dr. Vorwerk said that he could bring proof that the complainant too twenty-two books ani that only twenty were returned. The twenty books were probably returned because the defendant had complained to the police.

The Assessor said that the Court had now simply to deal with the matter of the pearls. These would either have to be returned or paid for.

en tually an order was made that the defendant be remanded in custody for a week, to see if he could either pay for or return the jewels.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account